Invisible Man (1954)

Item: Invisible Man
Rating: 2.5
Author: Ross McLaren

★★½ — Invisible Man (1954)

There's a moment in Toho's 1954 take on The Invisible Man where the film completely loses the plot. I mean that almost literally. Things have been ticking along reasonably well, there's genuine intrigue, a post-war Tokyo backdrop that gives the whole thing a distinctive flavour, some half-decent sci-fi tension about science running ahead of anyone's ability to control it, and then, out of nowhere, clowns. Actual clowns. And not in a way that serves the story or ratchets up the surreal dread. Just clowns, doing clown things, and the film's already fragile sense of atmosphere evaporates on the spot.

That's the central problem with this one, and it's a shame, because there's something genuinely interesting buried in here. Toho were clearly fascinated by the Universal monster cycle, and their instinct to transplant the invisible man premise into a Japanese, post-war context was a smart one. The ruins and reconstruction of Tokyo in the early fifties carry real weight. A story about a scientist who discovers invisibility and gradually unravels feels like it should resonate in that setting, where the consequences of scientific ambition had been catastrophically, visibly felt just a decade earlier. There's a film in that. A good one, possibly.

But this isn't quite that film. Instead of committing to gothic horror or pointed Cold War allegory, the film keeps hedging its bets. It wants to be a sci-fi thriller. It wants to be a slapstick comedy. It wants to say something serious about ethics and power. The result is that it does none of those things with any real conviction. The tonal lurches aren't the enjoyable kind of chaotic, either. They're the kind that make you wonder whether anyone sat down and worked out what story they were actually telling before cameras rolled.

The first half is, genuinely, the more interesting half. There are cool moments. The invisibility effects are handled with reasonable craft for the era, and there's an unsettling undercurrent to the early scenes that suggests the film knows exactly how creepy this premise can be. If you've seen The Invisible Man from 1933, you'll know what that version does so brilliantly is keep the horror and the dark comedy intertwined without ever letting one swamp the other. This version doesn't have that discipline. The comedy overwhelms, and then the clowns arrive, and you're just sat there wondering what happened.

It's worth saying, for context: if you're deep into Toho's output beyond Godzilla, this is a curiosity you'll probably want to tick off. I've spent time with their catalogue, and films like Godzilla Raids Again (1955) show what the studio was capable of when they leaned into genre with a bit more focus. This one feels like they were still working out their range, throwing ideas at the screen and seeing what stuck. Quite a lot doesn't stick.

The Cold War paranoia angle is underdeveloped but tantalising. There are flashes of something sharper, something that might have made this a film people talk about rather than a footnote. But then it derails again, and you're back to wondering whether this is meant to be fun or frightening or a bit of both. The answer, frustratingly, is that it's a bit of all three, and not very much of any of them.

Two and a half stars feels about right. There's enough here to justify a single watch if you're curious, and the setting alone earns it some goodwill. But goodwill only goes so far. The clown stuff made absolutely zero sense, and I'm not sure I'll ever fully forgive it for that.

Rating: ★★½ | Year: 1954 | Watched: 2025-10-30

View on Letterboxd →

Related on Movies With Macca