Tuna: A Fish with a Special Place in My Heart (2012)

Right, so here's the thing: if you don't particularly care about tuna, this film is not going to do much for you. And I say that not to be dismissive, but because it's genuinely the most honest thing I can tell you going in. I watched this as part of my A-Z World Movie Tour, with Palau as the destination, and this is what Palau gave me. A man, his memories, and a lot of tuna.

The film is essentially one person's memoir delivered to camera. He narrates his way through his life, pulling in stories about family, about where he's from, about identity, and threading through all of it is tuna. Always tuna. It comes back to tuna the way some people's stories come back to a hometown, or a parent, or a defining moment. For this fella, it's the fish. And fair enough, honestly. There's something almost admirable about that level of singular focus.

The style is what you'd call selfie filmmaking, and I don't mean that as a compliment or a criticism, just a description. It's bare bones. The narration is recorded in that slightly flat, close-mic'd way you get when someone's talking straight into their phone or a basic recorder. The b-roll footage is functional rather than beautiful. There's no real cinematic flourish to speak of, no score doing heavy lifting, no clever editing to give it shape. It just... goes. He talks, we see footage, he talks some more.

Now, I've seen stripped-back documentary work done brilliantly. Something like Letter from Siberia (1957) shows you how much personality and intelligence can be packed into a modest format. This doesn't quite get there. The personal connection between the narrator and his subject is clearly genuine, and there are moments where that sincerity comes through and you find yourself leaning in a little. A memory about family, a detail about life in Palau, something that makes the place feel real and specific rather than just a backdrop. Those moments work.

But they're scattered, and the film doesn't do enough to build around them. The structure is loose to the point of being almost shapeless. You're never quite sure where it's heading or what it wants you to feel by the end. It meanders through his life story in a way that could be meditative if it were handled with more care, but instead just feels like someone emptying their pockets and hoping you'll find something interesting in there.

I did find bits interesting, I'll be honest. The Palau angle kept me curious enough to stick with it, and the specificity of tuna as a cultural and personal touchstone is genuinely unusual territory for a documentary. I just wish the filmmaking had done more with it. A bit more structure, a bit more visual ambition, and this could have been something quietly affecting. As it stands, it's a modest personal project that probably means a great deal to the person who made it and considerably less to everyone else.

One and a half stars, and that half star is entirely for the moments where his sincerity cuts through. If you're doing your own world movie tour and Palau comes up, well, this is your lot. Go in with low expectations and an interest in fish, and you might get something out of it. Otherwise, probably not one to chase down.

Rating: ★½  | Year: 2012  | Watched: 2025-08-08

View on Letterboxd →

Related on Movies With Macca

More from the 2010s: Wonder (2017) · Beautiful Boy (2018) · The Witch (2015) · What We Do in the Shadows (2014)
More documentary: Letter from Siberia (1957) · Lessons of Darkness (1992) · Style Wars (1983) · Here and Elsewhere (1976)