Next Goal Wins (2014)
American Samoa is, by most conventional football metrics, about as far from the top of the world game as it is possible to get. A small archipelago in the South Pacific with a population of around 55,000, it fields a national side that, in the early 2000s, had become genuinely notorious for all the wrong reasons. The 31-0 defeat to Australia in a 2002 World Cup qualifier remains the heaviest loss in the history of international football, a result so extraordinary that it briefly made American Samoa famous in the way nobody actually wants to be famous. Next Goal Wins, the 2014 documentary from British filmmakers Mike Brett and Steve Jamison, takes that moment of infamy as its starting point and asks what comes next, tracking the team through a fresh qualifying campaign and finding, along the way, something considerably more interesting than a simple sporting comeback story.
Brett and Jamison were relatively early in their documentary careers when they followed the team, and the film reflects a sensibility that prioritises people over production polish. Shot with the kind of close access that only comes from genuine trust, it has the texture of something lived-in rather than constructed. The production, handled through the smaller British outfits K5 International, Agile Films and Archer's Mark, keeps things lean, and the budget is clearly modest, though that works in the film's favour. There is no gloss here, no corporate sheen. At 97 minutes, it moves at a pace that never outstays its welcome. The result sits comfortably alongside other character-led documentary work you might find on the festival circuit, though it earned a wider release than most in its category. If you have an appetite for this kind of observational filmmaking, you might also enjoy the approach taken in Lost Boy in Juba or the quietly personal register of Luigi, both of which find big emotional territory through small-scale, intimate storytelling.
The human material at the centre of the film is, frankly, exceptional. Dutch-American coach Thomas Rongen arrives in American Samoa with a complicated personal history and a professional record that makes him, on paper, an unlikely saviour figure. He is prickly, demanding, and not especially given to sentimentality, which turns out to be precisely what makes him interesting to watch. Goalkeeper Nicky Salapu carries the particular burden of having been on the pitch for that 31-0 result, and his presence gives the film a thread of personal reckoning that runs quietly through the whole piece. Then there is Jaiyah Saelua, who plays as a fa'afafine (a third gender identity recognised in Samoan culture long before Western frameworks entered the conversation) and whose role in the squad the film handles with a thoughtfulness that was, in 2014, rather ahead of where mainstream sports coverage tended to sit. The ensemble around them, including Larry Mana'o and Rawlston Masaniai, fills out a portrait of a community that is anything but a punchline. For other documentary perspectives rooted in specific cultural communities, the blog's review of Cachada: The Opportunity covers similar ground in a different corner of the world.
Next Goal Wins (2014) is an incredibly uplifting documentary that chronicles the American Samoa national football team’s journey from global infamy to hard-earned redemption. Widely known for a historic 31–0 defeat to Australia in 2001, the squad was branded the worst team in international football. But rather than leaning into mockery or pity, the film crafts a deeply human story about struggle, grit, and quiet triumph.
Directors Mike Brett and Steve Jamison follow the team through a grueling World Cup qualifying campaign, capturing not just their tactical development, but the emotional weight of representing a small island community with limited resources, vast distances, and enormous cultural pride. The result is a sports documentary that cares far more about character than trophies.
What truly elevates the film is its respectful, unflinching portrayal of Jaiyah Saelua, a transgender woman who plays on the men’s national team as a fa’aafafia (a historically recognised third gender in Samoan culture). The documentary never treats her identity as a sidebar or a novelty; instead, it centres her skill, leadership, and resilience as integral to the team’s spirit. Her presence offers a powerful reminder of how Polynesian societies have long embraced gender diversity with dignity, a perspective the wider world still has much to learn from. In this regard, Next Goal Wins shares the same cultural warmth and reverent storytelling as Kumu Hina, another exceptional documentary that celebrates Indigenous Pacific transgender identity.
The filmmaking is sharp, intimate, and deeply empathetic, balancing on-field tension with off-field vulnerability without ever sensationalising poverty, failure, or identity. It’s not about winning matches; it’s about showing up, earning respect, and reclaiming pride. Uplifting without being saccharine, Next Goal Wins is an incredible documentary that transcends the typical sports underdog formula. A celebration of community, cultural acceptance, and quiet perseverance that reminds us why sport (and the people who play it) still matters.
What Next Goal Wins demonstrates, four stars and all, is that the sports documentary format is at its best when the sport is almost beside the point. The football here is the frame, not the picture. Brett and Jamison found a story about identity, belonging, and what a small community can carry on its shoulders, and they had the good sense to let it breathe. For anyone who came to this film via Taika Waititi's 2023 fictional remake of the same name (a considerably louder, more uneven affair), the original documentary is the version worth seeking out. It is harder to find now than it deserves to be, which is a shame. Some films are best watched without fanfare, in a quiet room, preferably with a drink to hand. This is one of them.
Rating: ★★★★ | Year: 2014 | Watched: 2026-06-03
Trailer
▶ Watch the official trailer for Next Goal Wins (2014) on YouTube
Where to watch (UK)
Rent: Apple TV Store · Rakuten TV · Amazon Video · Sky Store
Buy: Apple TV Store · Rakuten TV · Amazon Video · Google Play Movies
Physical: Amazon UK · Zavvi
Affiliate disclosure: Movies With Macca may earn a small commission on purchases or subscriptions started via these links. It costs you nothing extra.
