The Witch (2015)

There's a moment in The Witch where the dread isn't coming from anything you can point at on screen. It's the forest. Just the forest, sitting there at the edge of the frame, dark and patient and utterly indifferent. Robert Eggers earns that feeling honestly, and it's the film's greatest achievement. It's also, if I'm being straight with you, about as close to a traditional scare as the film ever gets.

Set in 1630s New England, this is the story of a devout Puritan family cast out from their plantation and forced to scratch a life from the land at the edge of a vast, foreboding wood. What follows is less a horror film in the conventional sense and more a slow psychological dismantling: of faith, of family, of sanity. Eggers has clearly done his homework. The production design, the costuming, the whole texture of the thing feels painstakingly, almost obsessively, authentic. And the soundscape, low whispers, animal cries, strings that seem to be tuned slightly wrong, keeps you coiled and tense long before anything overtly supernatural creeps into view.

The practical effects and creature work are genuinely unsettling, rooted in European folklore rather than the kind of horror shorthand we've all seen a hundred times. When the film does show you something, it's strange and specific in a way that sticks with you. This isn't the jumpy, gotcha school of horror. It's closer in spirit to something like Blair Witch, where the terror lives in suggestion, in what might be moving just beyond the treeline.

And the ending. I won't say more than that it works. It's quiet, chilling, and thematically coherent in a way that a lot of horror finales simply aren't. It lands.

But here's where I have to be honest about my mixed feelings, because I do have them. The archaic dialogue is a double-edged thing. In principle, I admire the ambition of it. In practice, there are stretches where the characters sound less like real people weathering genuine terror and more like they're delivering a reading at a very intense church service. The historical authenticity creates distance as often as it creates immersion, and that emotional remove makes it harder to feel the full weight of what this family is losing. You understand their plight intellectually before you feel it in your gut, and for a horror film, that's a real limitation.

The pacing is deliberate to the point of demanding patience from its audience. I think that's a fair creative choice, and I respect it, but I also can't pretend the film doesn't occasionally try that patience. There are moments where the slow burn tips into something that feels closer to stasis, and when the characters feel a little like vessels for thematic ideas rather than people, those slower passages can start to drag.

None of that undoes what's genuinely impressive here. Eggers has made something singular and committed. The atmosphere is oppressive in the best way. The folkloric imagery is vivid and memorable. And there's an intelligence to the whole project that puts it well clear of most of what passes for arthouse horror. It's the kind of film that lingers, that you find yourself turning over in your head a day or two later.

I think of it alongside something like What We Do in the Shadows (2014), another film that takes its supernatural mythology seriously on its own terms, though Eggers is going somewhere far darker and altogether less fun. Both films earn their world-building. The Witch just charges a heavier price for admission.

Three stars. A genuinely haunting piece of arthouse horror that stops just short of greatness, held back by emotional distance and a dialogue style that occasionally works against itself. Worth your time, but go in knowing what it is. This isn't a film that's going to meet you halfway.

Rating: ★★★  | Year: 2015  | Watched: 2026-05-05

View on Letterboxd →

Related on Movies With Macca

More from Russia: Police Story 4: First Strike (1996) · Anna (2019)
More from the 2010s: Wonder (2017) · Beautiful Boy (2018) · What We Do in the Shadows (2014) · Imperial Dreams (2014)
More drama: Viy (1967) · Wonder (2017) · A Better Tomorrow (1986) · Beautiful Boy (2018)
More thriller: Invasion of the Body Snatchers (1956) · Angst (1983) · The Long Walk (2025) · Punishment Park (1971)