Killer Mermaid (2014)
Franco Nero deserves better than this. That's not a particularly original observation, but sitting through Killer Mermaid, it's the thought that kept circling back to me. Here is an actor with genuine presence and a genuine legacy, turning up in a Montenegrin creature feature that can't even decide whether it wants to be a horror film or a bad joke. He commits, bless him. His delivery is measured and oddly believable given the chaos around him. But even Franco Nero can't bail out a film this comprehensively broken.
The setup is straightforward enough: a group of young tourists rock up to the stunning Adriatic coastline of Montenegro and, inevitably, awaken something ancient and hungry from beneath the water. On paper, that's a workable premise. Coastal isolation, a monster with mythology behind it, beautiful scenery that doubles as a kind of cruel irony when the blood starts flowing. It could have been fun. It really could. Instead, director Milan Todorović squanders every advantage he has, and Montenegro gives him quite a few.
Because here's the thing: the location is genuinely gorgeous. The rocky coastlines, the old fortifications, the shimmering blue of the Adriatic. It's all right there, and the film just doesn't seem interested. The cinematography is flat and poorly lit, framing everything with the kind of imagination you'd expect from a rushed second unit on a Tuesday afternoon. A better film would have made that scenery feel mythic and threatening. This one makes it feel like a backdrop hired by the day.
Then there's the mermaid herself. The CGI is embarrassingly weak, and I don't say that just to pile on a low-budget production. I understand limitations. What I struggle to forgive is when those limitations aren't worked around creatively, when a production just plonks its inadequate effects front and centre and hopes nobody notices. The creature looks like something rejected from a mid-2000s video game, and its attacks are edited with such incoherence that tension is impossible. What lands instead is unintentional comedy, which might be tolerable if the film had any self-awareness about it, but it doesn't.
The cast surrounding Nero fare considerably worse. Wooden line deliveries, chemistry so absent you'd think they filmed their scenes on different continents, and a script that gives them nothing to work with regardless. It sits firmly in that Syfy-channel-at-3am tier, the kind of film that exists not to entertain but simply to exist. To fill a slot. To get uploaded to a streaming platform and quietly accumulate accidental views from people who fell asleep and woke up to something unexpected.
I love a good creature feature, genuinely. I've got a lot of time for horror that leans into its silliness with commitment and craft, the kind of gleeful genre filmmaking you get in something like Re-Animator (1985), where the absurdity is worn proudly and the energy never drops. Killer Mermaid has none of that spark. It's not so-bad-it's-good. It's just bad. The distinction matters, because so-bad-it's-good requires a certain accidental energy, a film failing interestingly. This one fails in the most boring ways imaginable.
Unless you're chasing down every Franco Nero appearance for completism's sake, or you're specifically researching how not to light a coastal location, there is genuinely no reason to watch this. It's a low-effort, poorly conceived entry in an already overcrowded field, and no amount of Montenegrin sunshine can warm it up.
One star.
Rating: ★ | Year: 2014 | Watched: 2026-05-29
Where to watch
Watch in the UK
Physical: Amazon UK · Zavvi
Watch in the US
Stream: Amazon Prime Video · Amazon Prime Video with Ads
Rent: Amazon Video · Fandango At Home
Buy: Amazon Video · Fandango At Home
Physical: Amazon US
Affiliate disclosure: Movies With Macca may earn a small commission on purchases or subscriptions started via these links. It costs you nothing extra.
