The Seventh Seal (1957)
There is a slightly awkward truth I have had to make my peace with after working my way through a fair chunk of Ingmar Bergman's filmography: I keep coming away respecting these films rather than loving them. I admire them. I think about them afterwards. And then I realise that admiring a film and being moved by it are two very different things, and that the gap between the two is exactly where my feelings about Bergman tend to live.
The Seventh Seal is no exception, and if anything the gap feels wider here than anywhere else, because this is the one. The 1957 film that made his name internationally, the one that gave world cinema one of its most enduring images: Max von Sydow's knight, freshly returned from the Crusades, sitting across a chessboard from Death himself on a bleak Swedish shoreline, buying time against the inevitable while a plague tears through the land around him. As premises go, it is an absolute stone-cold icon, and I would never deny it that. The chess game, the final dance of death silhouetted against the sky, these images have lasted for a reason. They deserve to last.
And there is a great deal to genuinely respect in the film around those images. It wrestles with faith, doubt and mortality as seriously as almost anything I can think of, and it does so without flinching or reaching for easy comfort. The ideas carry real weight. I felt that weight. The trouble is that feeling the weight of an argument and enjoying the experience of sitting through it are, again, not quite the same thing, and I found The Seventh Seal desperately slow, almost wall-to-wall with characters standing about discoursing on God and death and the silence of the universe. The craft is precise, the acting is committed, and the philosophical ambition is genuine. I just kept finding myself restless rather than rapt.
It is the same reservation that nagged at me through Persona and Winter Light, a sense that Bergman is always speaking to me from a considerable intellectual height, and that I am straining to keep up not because the ideas are beyond me but because the films themselves sometimes seem to mistake austerity for engagement. Seriousness is not enough on its own. A film still has to hold you.
Which leads me to a thought I cannot quite shake, and I know it is going to sound heretical. I do genuinely wonder how much of this film's towering reputation is earned in the actual watching, and how much is the cinephile reflex of deferring to other cinephiles, a kind of inherited reverence that gets passed down without anyone stopping to ask whether the film is still actually gripping a modern audience. I felt something sharper and more certain of that watching The Passion of Joan of Arc. Here it is milder, more of a nagging suspicion than a firm conclusion. But it is there. Important is not always the same as enthralling, and I think the two get blurred together more often than they should.
None of that is a dismissal. It is a good film, a serious and beautiful one, and anyone who finds it genuinely profound is responding to something real. The substance is there. I am not arguing it away. It simply did not move me the way its reputation had promised it would, and I would be doing nobody any favours by dressing respect up as rapture just because the consensus expects it.
Three and a half stars. Thoughtful, striking, and beautiful, and not quite great, at least not for me. Which is, if I am honest, more or less where Bergman and I always seem to end up.
Rating: ★★★½ | Year: 1957 | Watched: 2026-08-27
Where to watch
Watch in the UK
Stream: BFI Player · BFI Player Amazon Channel · BFI Player Apple TV Channel
Rent: Apple TV Store · Amazon Video
Buy: Apple TV Store · Amazon Video
Physical: Amazon UK · Zavvi
Watch in the US
Stream: HBO Max Amazon Channel · HBO Max
Rent: Amazon Video · Apple TV Store · Google Play Movies · YouTube
Buy: Amazon Video · Apple TV Store · Google Play Movies · YouTube
Physical: Amazon US
Affiliate disclosure: Movies With Macca may earn a small commission on purchases or subscriptions started via these links. It costs you nothing extra.
