Half Nelson (2006)
Ryan Fleck's Half Nelson arrived in 2006 as one of those small, scrappy American independent films that somehow punches well above its weight in the conversation it provokes. Shot on a modest budget by a collection of production companies including Hunting Lane Films and Original Media, it was co-written by Fleck and his regular collaborator Anna Boden, a partnership that would go on to shape some of the more quietly ambitious American indie work of the following decade. The film sits somewhere in the tradition of inner-city school dramas, but it is not particularly interested in the inspirational teacher template that Hollywood tends to reach for. Instead it occupies more uncomfortable, morally ambiguous territory: a Brooklyn junior-high history teacher who is dedicated to his students by day and consumed by crack cocaine by night, whose carefully maintained double life begins to unravel when one of his students discovers exactly who he is when the lights go down. It is the kind of premise that could easily tip into melodrama or, worse, into a tidy redemption arc, and the film is at least aware enough of that trap to sidestep the most obvious version of it.
Fleck and Boden were working in a broadly naturalistic register here, the sort of filmmaking that came out of the early 2000s American indie movement rather than from any studio development room. Cinematographer Andrij Parekh shot the film with a loose, close-quarters handheld style, favouring available light and the kind of grainy, slightly underexposed texture that keeps the viewer at ground level with the characters rather than above them. There is nothing glossy or composed about the images in any conventional sense: faces fill the frame in uncomfortable proximity, corridors feel genuinely narrow, and the basketball court sequences have the casual rhythm of something observed rather than staged. The editing was handled by Boden herself, and her choices are in keeping with that aesthetic, allowing scenes to breathe past the point where a more conventional cut would have intervened. Kevin Drew, best known as one half of Broken Social Scene, provided the score, which leans on spare, slightly mournful guitar and ambient textures rather than anything that announces itself as a film soundtrack. It is the kind of music that supports mood without editorialising, which suits the film's general reluctance to tell you exactly how to feel.
The film rests almost entirely on Ryan Gosling as Dan Dunne, a performance that earned him an Academy Award nomination and, for many people, announced him as something more than a young leading man in waiting. Shareeka Epps plays Drey, the student who becomes his unlikely confidante, and she matches Gosling's naturalism beat for beat, bringing a watchful, self-possessed quality to a role that could easily have been underwritten. Anthony Mackie, who I also covered in Captain America: Brave New World, appears in a supporting role as a local figure whose relationship with Drey runs parallel to Dunne's, adding a layer of complexity to the film's interest in who looks out for young people and what that protection costs. It is a polished but unremarkable supporting turn, though the film is not really asking him for more than that. Gosling's work here is worth setting alongside the very different kind of minimalism he brought to Drive and the more expansive register of The Place Beyond the Pines, both of which show how consistently he gravitates towards characters carrying something they cannot quite put down.
Half Nelson lives or dies on Ryan Gosling, and it is fortunate to have him. The premise is an interesting one, and Gosling, who is a tremendous actor, carries the whole thing largely on his own shoulders. I am not entirely sure I enjoyed it, though. There is a loose, handheld, almost documentary feel to the whole thing, at times it played less like a drama than a mockumentary, and for all its qualities I came away finding it a fairly middling watch.
I keep coming back to the thought that without Gosling in the lead, this would not be rated anywhere near as highly as it is. He is the thing holding it together. As for what it is about, it is a story of loneliness and of finding your allies in unlikely places, but underneath that it is about a teacher with a serious drug habit, and a bond with one of his students that is hugely inappropriate. The film does not shy away from how troubling that is, to its credit, but it also did not give me a great deal to hold onto beyond Gosling's performance.
My other frustration is that it left a lot hanging. I would have liked some sense of how these characters' lives actually turn out, and instead it ends feeling oddly unresolved, trailing off rather than arriving anywhere. Three stars. A fine showcase for a very good actor doing a lot with tricky material, but a middling film that never quite pulled me in or paid me off.
Half Nelson is, in the end, a film that is easier to respect than to love, which is perhaps fitting for a story about people who are easier to understand than to help. Fleck and Boden went on to develop a body of work with genuine ambition, and this remains a creditable early marker of that. For a companion piece in a similar vein, see also The Florida Project, another film that watches adults and children negotiate a world that has not arranged itself around their needs. Half Nelson will stay with you in proportion to how much Gosling stays with you, and for some viewers that will be quite enough. For others, it may feel like watching a very good actor work very hard in a room with the windows painted shut.
Rating: ★★★ | Year: 2006 | Watched: 2026-10-07
Trailer
▶ Watch the official trailer for Half Nelson (2006) on YouTube
Where to watch
Watch in the UK
Stream: Amazon Prime Video · Icon Film Amazon Channel · Amazon Prime Video with Ads
Rent: Apple TV Store · Amazon Video · Google Play Movies · Sky Store
Buy: Apple TV Store · Amazon Video · Google Play Movies · Sky Store
Physical: Amazon UK · Zavvi
Watch in the US
Stream: Amazon Prime Video · fuboTV · Amazon Prime Video with Ads
Rent: Apple TV Store · Google Play Movies · YouTube
Buy: Apple TV Store · Google Play Movies · YouTube
Physical: Amazon US
Affiliate disclosure: Movies With Macca may earn a small commission on purchases or subscriptions started via these links. It costs you nothing extra.
