Modern Times (1936)
By 1936, the silent film era was not merely over, it was already being mythologised. Sound had swept through Hollywood with a speed that left careers in ruins and whole aesthetic traditions looking suddenly antique. Charlie Chaplin, who had built the most recognisable screen character in cinema history with his Tramp, resisted the transition longer than almost anyone of comparable stature, and Modern Times represents his final, qualified concession to that new world. The film retains the grammar of silent comedy, pantomime physicality, intertitles, a largely non-dialogue soundtrack, while flirting with synchronised sound in carefully controlled bursts. It arrived in a world gripped by economic depression and industrial anxiety, and its satirical premise, a factory worker ground down by mechanisation and misfortune, gave it a political charge that some critics read as socialist sympathising (which caused Chaplin no small amount of trouble in the years that followed).
The film was produced entirely under Chaplin's own banner, Charles Chaplin Productions, which gave him a degree of creative control few directors of the period could have dreamed of. He wrote the screenplay, composed the score, co-edited alongside Willard Nico, and naturally took the lead role. That level of authorial ownership was both his great strength and, depending on your perspective, a source of the film's occasional self-indulgence. For a companion piece from the same year that takes a rather different approach to Depression-era comedy, see also My Man Godfrey, and for a European take on working-class anxieties in the same twelve months, I also reviewed The Crime of Monsieur Lange, which makes for an interesting contrast in tone and politics.
The cast around Chaplin is modest but well-chosen. Paulette Goddard, who was in a long-term relationship with Chaplin at the time of production, plays the Gamine with a scrappy, warm energy that keeps the film's romantic thread from feeling purely incidental. Henry Bergman, Chester Conklin, and Tiny Sandford fill out the supporting world with the kind of broad but reliable comic types that silent-era audiences would have recognised immediately. None of them are asked to do much beyond serve the Tramp's journey, but they do it without getting in the way, which is its own kind of skill. Those wanting more Chaplin to set against this might find my reviews of The Gold Rush and The Circus useful points of comparison across his silent period.
Cinematographers Ira H. Morgan and Roland Totheroh, the latter a long-standing Chaplin collaborator stretching back to the Mutual shorts, shoot the film in crisp black and white with clean, practical compositions. The factory sequences have a particular visual rhythm to them, all cogs and conveyor belts rendered with a geometry that reinforces the film's satirical point about human beings reduced to machine components. The imagery is functional rather than painterly, designed to foreground performance and gag construction rather than to call attention to itself. Chaplin's own score sits somewhere between orchestral accompaniment and sound design, using recorded music and selective sound effects to create a world that feels curated rather than naturalistic. Most famously, when Chaplin's Tramp finally does produce a vocal sound, it arrives as deliberate nonsense, a joke at the expense of the very idea of dialogue cinema rather than any kind of capitulation to it.
The more Chaplin I watch, the more I accept that he is simply not my silent comedian of choice. Give me Buster Keaton or Laurel and Hardy any day. There is a daring and a precision to Keaton in particular, in something like The General, that Chaplin's films have never quite matched for me. Modern Times is held up as one of the greatest films ever made, and for all I can see what people value in it, it simply does not land that way in my eyes.
As for the film itself, I found the first half a good deal stronger than the second, which rather runs out of steam as it goes along. And I will not labour the point I made about City Lights, because it applies here just as squarely: judged against its silent-era peers this is up there with the best of them, but set against the hundreds of films that followed, with everything cinema has gained since, it simply does not compare. That gap, for me, is too wide to ignore.
None of which is to deny Chaplin's gifts or his importance; the man changed the medium, and I would not argue otherwise. It is more that, as a viewing experience in 2026, his films leave me a touch cold where others of the era still delight me. Three stars. A significant film, no question, but one that only confirmed Chaplin is not for me, and left me reaching, once again, for Keaton instead.
Modern Times sits in an unusual position in the canon, a film that almost everyone agrees matters enormously, while fewer people than its reputation implies will tell you they find it genuinely funny from beginning to end. Its place in film history is not in question: as a document of one filmmaker's stubborn resistance to technological change, as a piece of Depression-era social commentary, and as a showcase for a physical comedy tradition that was already beginning to fade, it earns its status. Whether it earns your affection across nearly ninety years of cinema that followed it is a rather different question, and one that only the honest viewer can answer for themselves. The Tramp walks off into the distance at the end, as he so often does, and the image is undeniably lovely. Whether you feel anything much when he goes is between you and the screen.
Rating: ★★★ | Year: 1936 | Watched: 2026-10-21
Trailer
▶ Watch the official trailer for Modern Times (1936) on YouTube
Where to watch
Watch in the UK
Stream: Amazon Prime Video · Amazon Prime Video with Ads
Rent: Amazon Video
Buy: Apple TV Store · Amazon Video
Physical: Amazon UK · Zavvi
Watch in the US
Stream: Amazon Prime Video · HBO Max Amazon Channel · YouTube TV · Criterion Channel
Rent: Amazon Video · Apple TV Store · Fandango At Home
Buy: Amazon Video · Apple TV Store · Fandango At Home
Physical: Amazon US
Affiliate disclosure: Movies With Macca may earn a small commission on purchases or subscriptions started via these links. It costs you nothing extra.