Maharaja (2024)

Share
Maharaja (2024)

Maharaja arrived in Indian cinemas in June 2024 as one of the more talked-about Tamil-language releases of the year, picking up considerable word-of-mouth on the back of its non-linear structure and a premise that keeps its audience deliberately off-balance. Produced by Passion Studios, The Route and Think Studios, the film sits in the busy overlap between action thriller and mystery, a corner of Tamil cinema that has grown increasingly crowded as the industry finds bigger international audiences through streaming. Writer-director Nithilan Saminathan, working from his own screenplay, had previously made Kannum Kannum Kollaiyadithaal (2020), a slick romantic thriller that announced him as a filmmaker with a genuine appetite for plot mechanics. Maharaja is, in many ways, a more ambitious swing: a revenge story whose central conceit involves a barber, a stolen household object he has named Lakshmi, and a police force that cannot quite work out what they are being asked to look for. The premise is a good one. Whether the film makes the most of it is, of course, another question.

The cast is led by Vijay Sethupathi, one of the most bankable and critically respected actors working in Tamil cinema right now, the kind of performer whose involvement alone generates anticipation. Alongside him is Anurag Kashyap, better known internationally as a director (he made the two-part Gangs of Wasseypur, a landmark of Indian crime cinema) but an increasingly visible screen presence in his own right. Sachana Namidass plays the barber's daughter, a role that sits at the emotional centre of the story, while Natarajan Subramaniam and Abhirami round out the principal ensemble. On paper, this is a cast with genuine range to draw on.

The film's look is the work of cinematographer Dinesh Purushothaman, whose framing tends toward close, pressured compositions that suit the material's atmosphere of mounting dread. There is a texture to his lighting choices, a tendency to let interiors sit in partial shadow, that keeps the visual tone consistent even when the narrative is jumping between timelines. The editing by Philomin Raj, a regular collaborator with some of Tamil cinema's busiest directors, is central to how the film handles its structural puzzle: the cutting between time periods and perspectives is, by design, the mechanism through which the mystery builds. The score is by B. Ajaneesh Loknath, the Kannada-language composer who made considerable noise with his work on Kantara (2022), and who brings a similar taste for low, rolling tension here, building pressure through texture rather than obvious melodic statement. For a companion piece in non-linear South Asian storytelling, you might also find my thoughts on 3 Idiots worth a look, though that film operates in an entirely different register. I also covered Candyman, another genre film that arrives with significant creative expectations and tries to balance sharp structural ideas with visceral action, if that kind of comparison interests you.

Maharaja is a deeply frustrating watch, because buried inside it is a smart, twisty screenplay that deserved a far better film around it.

Start with the acting, which is abysmal. Vijay Sethupathi, in the lead, has one move that he returns to over and over: he walks up to someone, asks a question, gets stonewalled, then asks again, softer, and keeps softly repeating it until they cave. Once is a quirk. By the tenth time it is maddening. The daughter is no better, and between them they drain a lot of the tension out of scenes.

It is also far too long. It runs well over two hours and feels considerably longer than that. And it is odd from the very start, in ways I will not fully spoil (but quite typical melodrama for this genre). The hook is that our man reveres a battered old dustbin he calls Lakshmi, because years earlier it saved his daughter's life, and when it is stolen in a break-in he sets out to get it back. From there the plot spirals off somewhere far wilder, a full-blown melodrama of crime, violence and intrigue, and I did not for a moment see where it was heading.

And here is the maddening part: the writing itself is excellent. The twists and turns are clever and they land, and on the page this could have been something special. But a good script can only carry you so far when everything around it lets it down.

The fight scenes are especially poor, the choreography basic and clumsy, and you can see it plainly reaching for the raw, bruising power of Oldboy, whose corridor fight I rate among the finest ever filmed, and getting nowhere near it.

Two stars. A poor film, then, but one with the bones of an exceptional one, which somehow makes it more disappointing than if it had simply been bad all the way through.

Maharaja is, by any measure, a film of parts that do not fully add up. Its premise is genuinely inventive, its structural ambitions are clear, and the production brings together real talent both in front of and behind the camera. But there is a particular kind of frustration reserved for films that give you enough of the good stuff to know exactly what you are missing, and this one sits squarely in that category. For anyone with a broader interest in how action thrillers handle non-linear storytelling, or indeed how genre cinema can stumble between a strong script and a finished film, see also Miami Vice for a film that similarly divides opinion on the gap between intention and execution, and I wrote about Paradise as another example of genre filmmaking that reaches for something distinctive and lands somewhere more complicated. Maharaja will find its defenders, and it probably deserves them, at least in part. But a promising skeleton is not quite the same thing as a film.


Rating: ★★ | Year: 2024 | Watched: 2026-10-03

View on Letterboxd →


Trailer

▶ Watch the official trailer for Maharaja (2024) on YouTube


Where to watch

Watch in the UK
Stream:
Netflix · Netflix Standard with Ads
Physical: Amazon UK · Zavvi

Watch in the US
Stream:
Netflix · Netflix Standard with Ads
Physical: Amazon US

Affiliate disclosure: Movies With Macca may earn a small commission on purchases or subscriptions started via these links. It costs you nothing extra.

Film images and data courtesy of TMDB. This product uses the TMDB API but is not endorsed or certified by TMDB.