3 Idiots (2009)
The hype can be a killer. I went into 3 Idiots having been told by what felt like half the internet that it was one of the funniest films ever made, a stone-cold classic, an absolute must-see. I'm a huge fan of Sholay, so I have plenty of time for Indian cinema, and I was fully prepared to spend three hours in stitches. What I got was something a bit more complicated than that.
Rajkumar Hirani's 2009 Bollywood mega-hit follows three engineering students, played with real warmth by Aamir Khan, R. Madhavan and Sharman Joshi, navigating the crushing pressures of one of India's most competitive academic environments. On paper, that's a rich setup with loads of comic potential, genuine emotional stakes, and something real to say about how societies treat their young people. And to its credit, the film does deliver on all of those things, just not always in the way I was hoping for.
Here's my honest problem: a lot of the comedy felt pitched somewhere around a children's TV show. Broad slapstick, wildly exaggerated facial expressions, cartoonish sound effects. There were moments where I felt like I was watching a particularly lively episode of something aimed at ten-year-olds rather than a comedy being celebrated by adults the world over. That's not a complaint about Bollywood as a form, it's just a personal reaction to this particular film's comic register. I did laugh out loud a few times, genuinely, but nowhere near as often as the hype had primed me to expect.
The musical numbers are exactly what you'd expect from a production of this scale, big, colourful, full of energy, and they contribute to the larger-than-life atmosphere Hirani is clearly going for. I'm not going to pretend I wasn't entertained by them, because I was. But when you're sitting with a film that runs close to three hours, the laughs need to be hitting consistently to keep the momentum going, and for long stretches here, the comedy was just sort of fine rather than joyous.
What saves it, genuinely, is the heart. When 3 Idiots steps back from the zany stuff and focuses on the suffocating weight of parental expectation, academic pressure, and the very real human cost of a system that measures worth entirely through grades and rankings, it lands with real force. The bonds between the three leads feel earned and warm, and there are moments, particularly in the film's quieter emotional beats, where it gets to you in ways you weren't quite expecting. That tonal shift from knockabout comedy to something more sincere is where the film justifies a lot of the love people have for it.
I've been thinking about how this compares to other South Asian films that carry big cultural footprints. When I watched RRR (2022), I had a similar experience of adjusting to a register that isn't shy about its own scale and emotion, though that one grabbed me more firmly from the off. With 3 Idiots, the adjustment took longer, and I'm not sure I ever fully got there.
Three stars. It's a genuinely well-meaning film with a message worth hearing, and I completely understand why it connects so deeply with so many people. The central friendship is lovely, and Hirani clearly cares about what he's saying. It just didn't blow my mind the way I'd been led to believe it would. A perfectly enjoyable, feel-good ride, with a big heart at its centre. Worth your time, absolutely. But maybe go in with slightly earthier expectations than I managed.
Rating: ★★★ | Year: 2009 | Watched: 2026-06-23
Where to watch
Watch in the UK
Rent: Google Play Movies · YouTube
Buy: Google Play Movies · YouTube
Physical: Amazon UK · Zavvi
Watch in the US
Rent: Google Play Movies · YouTube
Buy: Google Play Movies · YouTube
Physical: Amazon US
Affiliate disclosure: Movies With Macca may earn a small commission on purchases or subscriptions started via these links. It costs you nothing extra.
