The Producers (1967)

Share
The Producers (1967)

Mel Brooks arrived in Hollywood having spent years sharpening his comedic instincts on television, most notably as a writer on Your Show of Shows, the celebrated early-fifties variety programme that also nurtured Carl Reiner, Neil Simon and Woody Allen. The Producers, released in 1967, was his feature debut as both writer and director, and it announced him as a filmmaker with no interest whatsoever in restraint or good taste. The premise is a genuinely audacious one: a fading Broadway impresario and his timid accountant cook up a scheme to oversell shares in a production they intend to make catastrophically bad, banking on a flop to cover their tracks. The show they settle on is a Hitler musical. That The Producers went on to win Brooks the Academy Award for Best Original Screenplay, and that it later spawned a hugely successful stage musical revival and a 2005 film adaptation of that revival, tells you something about the cultural grip it has maintained for over half a century. Whether the film itself earns that reputation is, of course, another matter.

Produced through a patchwork of small independent companies and distributed by AVCO Embassy Pictures, the film was made on a modest budget and with a scrappy, anything-goes energy to match. That independence from the major studios gave Brooks considerable creative freedom, which he used to push the material into territory that mainstream Hollywood would almost certainly have softened. The script leans hard on theatrical caricature and on the tradition of Jewish-American comic performance: broad, physical, operatic in its emotional swings. Zero Mostel, a veteran of stage and screen whose career had been blighted by the Hollywood blacklist in the early fifties, takes the lead as the scheming producer Max Bialystock, and his performance sits squarely in a tradition of vaudeville-inflected, large-bodied comedy. Opposite him, Gene Wilder makes his feature film debut as Leo Bloom, the nervous, put-upon accountant drawn into the fraud. Wilder had come up through the theatre and was, at this point, almost entirely unknown to cinema audiences. The supporting cast includes Dick Shawn as the hippie actor cast as Hitler, Kenneth Mars as the play's demented Nazi playwright, and Estelle Winwood as one of the elderly investors Bialystock sets out to charm.

Cinematographer Joseph F. Coffey shoots the film in a style that is deliberately stagey and unshowy, which suits a story set in the world of Broadway theatricals but also means the film rarely opens up visually in the way that great screen comedy tends to. The editing, by Ralph Rosenblum, who would go on to cut several of Woody Allen's early films including Annie Hall, keeps the pace brisk enough that the film never really drags, even when individual scenes overstay their welcome. John Morris, beginning here what would become a long and fruitful collaboration with Brooks across films like Blazing Saddles and Young Frankenstein, provides a score that cheerfully pastisches Broadway showmanship, brass-heavy and deliberately overblown, a musical wink at the pomposity it accompanies. The centrepiece production number, "Springtime for Hitler", is the sequence the film is best remembered for, a set-piece that uses scale and absurdity as a deliberate provocation. For a useful point of comparison with the big-budget British musicals being produced at the same moment, see also Oliver!, which won the Best Picture Oscar the following year and represents a very different approach to putting theatre on screen. And for another 1967 release that has aged into the status of a canonical work, I also reviewed Point Blank, which occupies a similarly charged place in its own genre's history.

I know The Producers is held up as a landmark of screen comedy, one of the films that supposedly rewrote the rulebook. I am afraid I just found it a bad one.

More than anything, it did not make me laugh, and for a comedy, acclaimed or otherwise, that is close to fatal. I spent most of it waiting to find it funny and never quite did.

A big part of the problem, for me, is Zero Mostel. His performance is pitched so broadly, so relentlessly melodramatic, that half the time it felt less like a sharp adult comedy and more like a children's cartoon crossed with a knockabout teen farce. I can see that the mugging and the mania are deliberate, part of the style, but it grated on me rather than winning me over, and it set a tone I could never get on board with.

Gene Wilder is a legend, needless to say, and nothing here changes that. But I do think he is miscast; he never quite seemed to fit the film, his particular brand of nervy, flustered genius a little at odds with everything around him. I understand it is meant as a satire on the showbusiness world, and on paper the premise, a scheme to profit by staging a guaranteed flop, is a good one. It simply did not come off for me. Two stars. Whatever its reputation and its influence, it left me stony-faced where it should have had me laughing, and that is the whole of it.

The Producers is one of those films whose reputation has become almost inseparable from the work itself, a title that gets invoked as shorthand for daring, transgressive comedy in a way that can make returning to the actual film a slightly disorienting experience. Gene Wilder's career would go on to confirm his particular gifts many times over, not least in Willy Wonka and the Chocolate Factory, where his brand of flustered, quietly eccentric energy found perhaps a more natural home. Brooks himself would find a more assured footing across later films that refined the anarchic approach on display here. Comedy, perhaps more than any other genre, lives or dies in the moment of watching, and no amount of canonical status can manufacture a laugh that the film itself fails to produce. That is the only test that really counts.


Rating: ★★ | Year: 1967 | Watched: 2026-10-25

View on Letterboxd →


Trailer

▶ Watch the official trailer for The Producers (1967) on YouTube


Where to watch

Watch in the UK
Stream:
Studiocanal Presents Amazon Channel
Rent: Apple TV Store · JustWatch TV Store · Amazon Video · Sky Store
Buy: Apple TV Store · Amazon Video · YouTube
Physical: Amazon UK · Zavvi

Watch in the US
Stream:
Lionsgate+ Amazon Channel · Howdy Amazon Channel
Rent: Amazon Video · Apple TV Store · Google Play Movies · YouTube
Physical: Amazon US

Affiliate disclosure: Movies With Macca may earn a small commission on purchases or subscriptions started via these links. It costs you nothing extra.

Film images and data courtesy of TMDB. This product uses the TMDB API but is not endorsed or certified by TMDB.