The Lighthouse (2019)

Share
The Lighthouse (2019)

Robert Eggers announced himself as a director worth watching with The Witch in 2015, a period horror that divided audiences sharply between those who found its slow, methodical dread hypnotic and those who found it punishing. The Lighthouse, his follow-up four years later, doubles down on every quality that made that debut so divisive. Shot in black and white and framed in the almost-square 1.19:1 aspect ratio of early twentieth-century photography, it plants itself firmly in the tradition of expressionist and art-house cinema rather than mainstream genre filmmaking. The setting is a remote New England island in the 1890s, and the premise is stripped to its bones: two men, a lighthouse, and an increasingly hostile relationship as their isolation deepens. The film arrived through a production partnership involving RT Features, Parts and Labor, Regency Enterprises and A24, the latter having by 2019 established itself as the go-to distributor for exactly this kind of polished but unremarkable-sounding pitch that turns out to be something far stranger once the lights go down.

The screenplay is credited to Robert Eggers and his brother Max Eggers, and draws on a fragment of an unfinished Edgar Allan Poe story as well as the real-life tragedy of two Welsh lighthouse keepers, Thomas and Joseph Griffith, whose 1801 ordeal reportedly inspired some of the material. Greek mythology, particularly the story of Prometheus, hangs over the whole project with considerable weight. It is the kind of source layering that signals authorial ambition loudly, and Eggers is clearly a director who wears his influences on his sleeve. For a companion piece in the A24 tradition of small, formally adventurous films, see also The Florida Project, Sean Baker's sun-bleached 2017 drama which shares that same commitment to a singular visual register, even if the worlds the two films inhabit could scarcely be more different.

The two roles are filled by Willem Dafoe and Robert Pattinson, and it would be difficult to imagine a more committed pairing. Dafoe, one of American cinema's great character actors, plays the grizzled senior keeper, all barnacled authority and baroque sea-dog monologue. Pattinson, whose career pivot after the Twilight Saga has been a sustained exercise in seeking out exactly the kind of difficult, unconventional work that franchise rarely demanded, plays the younger hand assigned to the menial labour while Dafoe guards the lamp above. The power imbalance between them is the engine of everything that follows. Valeriia Karaman, Logan Hawkes and Kyla Nicolle appear in supporting capacities, though the film is, by design, almost entirely a two-hander.

Cinematographer Jarin Blaschke, working here with Eggers for the second time after The Witch, shoots on orthochromatic-style lenses to mimic the photographic look of the period, producing images of considerable textural force: skies that churn with heavy grain, faces carved into near-theatrical contrast, the beam of the lighthouse rendered as something close to religious light. The chosen aspect ratio means the frame itself feels compressed, claustrophobic, almost like peering through a porthole. Mark Korven's score, also a returning collaboration from The Witch, leans on foghorns, low brass and queasy dissonance rather than conventional melody, building a soundscape that sits somewhere between maritime atmosphere and outright dread. Editor Louise Ford shapes material that is, by design, repetitive and circular, the rhythm of the cutting mirroring the grinding, hypnotic quality of the characters' deterioration.

I am sorry to say that The Lighthouse and I did not get on. More than anything, it felt to me like watching an Ingmar Bergman film, and since I am not a particularly big admirer of his, that is not the compliment it might sound.

It has that same austere, cerebral, deliberately difficult quality, the sort of film far more interested in ideas and psychology than in telling you a story, and that is rarely the mode I warm to.

Stripped back, it is essentially two men stuck on a rock, getting steadily drunk and slowly unravelling, their psyches laid bare as the isolation does its work. There is a strong current of homoerotic tension running through it, and the whole thing is plainly meant to be read philosophically rather than literally.

The ending, as best I could tell, is the culmination of the long power struggle between them, with the lighthouse light itself as the prize, and the final image, leaning hard on Greek myth, struck me as simply weird more than profound.

I came away thinking it rather overrated, admired far more widely than it ever landed for me. The one thing I will not quibble with is the acting, which is excellent from both men; they commit utterly to the madness, and the performances are the main reason this is not a lower score. Two and a half stars. Clearly the work of a serious film-maker with a serious vision, it simply was not a vision I had much time for.

The Lighthouse is the sort of film that tends to generate fierce loyalty among those it clicks with, and equally firm resistance in those it does not. Its festival reception was strong (it screened in the Un Certain Regard section at Cannes in 2019), and the critical consensus placed it among the more significant American films of that year. Whether that consensus holds up is, as ever, a matter of what you want from cinema on a given evening. If the idea of two extraordinary performances wrapped inside a formally rigorous, myth-saturated fever dream appeals, this is made with real craft and genuine conviction. If you prefer your films to move somewhere, to offer a story you can hold onto, you may find yourself on the outside of it, as I did. The light, it turns out, is not for everyone.


Rating: ★★½ | Year: 2019 | Watched: 2026-10-18

View on Letterboxd →


Trailer

▶ Watch the official trailer for The Lighthouse (2019) on YouTube


Where to watch

Watch in the UK
Rent:
Apple TV Store · Rakuten TV · Amazon Video · Sky Store
Buy: Apple TV Store · Rakuten TV · Amazon Video · Sky Store
Physical: Amazon UK · Zavvi

Watch in the US
Stream:
HBO Max Amazon Channel · HBO Max
Rent: Amazon Video · Apple TV Store · Google Play Movies · YouTube
Buy: Amazon Video · Apple TV Store · Google Play Movies · YouTube
Physical: Amazon US

Affiliate disclosure: Movies With Macca may earn a small commission on purchases or subscriptions started via these links. It costs you nothing extra.

Film images and data courtesy of TMDB. This product uses the TMDB API but is not endorsed or certified by TMDB.