My Own Private Idaho (1991)
River Phoenix is the reason to watch this film. That much is clear within the first few minutes, and it never stops being clear. As Mike, the narcoleptic street hustler drifting through the Pacific Northwest in search of a mother and a home he can barely picture, he is raw and tender and heartbreakingly present. He carries a kind of luminous, wounded openness that you cannot take your eyes off, and the whole thing only aches the more when you remember how young he was when we lost him, barely two years after this film came out. It is one of those performances that makes you grieve not just for a person but for everything they might have gone on to do.
I have now worked my way through a fair bit of Gus Van Sant, and he has become a director I trust to be interesting, even when he is not entirely successful. From the mainstream warmth of Good Will Hunting to the cold, formal daring of Elephant to the drifting teenage melancholy of Paranoid Park, his films tend to leave you with something worth chewing over. My Own Private Idaho sits very much in that mould: a rough, poetic, deeply felt character study that hands you plenty to think about, even where it stumbles.
The setup is deceptively simple. Two young men make their living hustling on the streets. Mike is the drifter, narcoleptic and longing, falling asleep in the middle of a sentence, a road, a moment of connection. Scott, played by Keanu Reeves, is the slumming son of a wealthy Portland family who knows perfectly well he can walk back into privilege the moment he feels like it. Out of that pairing Van Sant draws a quiet, searching commentary on class and belonging, on the families we are born into versus the ones we cobble together out of necessity and longing, and on queer lives lived at the margins at a time when mainstream cinema barely acknowledged they existed.
Reeves, who that same year was the all-action lead in Point Break, is quietly strong here in a far more inward register. There is a real, wounded tenderness between him and Phoenix, and the film earns that tenderness honestly. The score drifts and hums beneath it all to lovely effect, and Van Sant shoots the Pacific Northwest landscape with a kind of dreamy, aching beauty that suits the material perfectly.
Where it falls short of greatness, for me, is in the execution. It is rough around the edges in ways that are not always interesting. The Shakespearean sections, lifted and reworked from the Henry plays, do not always earn their keep, and there are stretches where the dreamy drift tips over into plain meandering. Van Sant is reaching for something ambitious and genuinely strange, and I respect that enormously, but ambition and achievement are not always the same thing, and the film never quite pulls all its threads into a satisfying shape. It ends and you feel slightly adrift, which is partly the point and partly, I think, a structural problem.
But here is the thing: that feeling does not go away. The roughness, which is also part of its honesty, lingers in a way that tighter, neater films often do not. The image of Mike waking up alone on a deserted road, the sky huge above him, stays with you. Phoenix stays with you. The film's ache for home, for connection, for someone to simply belong to stays with you. It does not all work, but what works, works beautifully.
Three and a half stars. A tender, ragged, quietly important piece of work, and if nothing else, an essential document of River Phoenix at his luminous best.
Rating: ★★★½ | Year: 1991 | Watched: 2026-08-30
Where to watch
Watch in the UK
Stream: HBO Max Amazon Channel · HBO Max
Rent: Apple TV Store · Amazon Video · Google Play Movies · Sky Store
Buy: Apple TV Store · Amazon Video · Google Play Movies · Sky Store
Physical: Amazon UK · Zavvi
Watch in the US
Rent: Amazon Video · Apple TV Store · Google Play Movies · YouTube
Buy: Amazon Video · Apple TV Store · Google Play Movies · YouTube
Physical: Amazon US
Affiliate disclosure: Movies With Macca may earn a small commission on purchases or subscriptions started via these links. It costs you nothing extra.
