Paranoid Park (2007)
Gus Van Sant arrived at Paranoid Park fresh from one of the more celebrated stretches of his career. His loosely connected "Death Trilogy" (comprising Gerry, Elephant, and Last Days) had established him as one of American independent cinema's most formally adventurous directors, a filmmaker willing to strip narrative back to its barest, most observational bones. Paranoid Park sits comfortably in that tradition. Based on Blake Nelson's 2006 young adult novel of the same name, the film follows Alex, a teenager from Portland, Oregon, whose visits to a notorious and slightly lawless skate park called Paranoid Park lead to a catastrophic incident involving a security guard. What follows is less a conventional crime thriller and more a quiet, fractured portrait of guilt, adolescence, and the peculiar isolation of carrying a secret that cannot be shared. The film was a co-production between French outfit mk2 Films and the Oregon-based Meno Film Company, shot on a modest budget that suits its deliberately unpolished, lo-fi aesthetic. It premiered at the Cannes Film Festival, where it won the 60th Anniversary Prize, which tells you something about the crowd it was pitching to.
Van Sant made a conscious decision to cast largely non-professional teenagers alongside a small number of more experienced actors, a choice that gives the film a raw, documentary-adjacent texture in its quieter moments. Gabe Nevins, who had no prior acting experience and was discovered through a MySpace casting call (very 2006), carries the central role of Alex. Taylor Momsen, then best known for her television work and shortly to become rather more famous for other reasons, appears in a supporting role alongside Dan Liu and Jake Miller. The professional cinematographer brought in to lend the film its distinctive visual identity was Christopher Doyle, the legendary Hong Kong-based Australian known for his long collaboration with Wong Kar-wai on films like In the Mood for Love and Chungking Express. That is quite a pairing: a first-time teenage lead and one of the most technically accomplished camera operators working anywhere in world cinema. Whether that combination produces something greater than the sum of its parts is, of course, the question.
Gus Van Sant’s 2007 feature Paranoid Park opens with a distinct, hazy visual rhythm that immediately sets it apart from your standard teenage drama.
Christopher Doyle’s cinematography is genuinely striking, capturing the concrete bowls and skate parks of Portland with a dreamlike, almost hypnotic quality. Paired with a decidedly moody, atmospheric soundtrack, the film establishes a compelling mood for what is, at its core, a rather good coming-of-age story. The narrative handles its central, dark premise (a catastrophic, life-altering accident) with a fragmented, teasing exposition that slowly pieces together the truth, leading to a reveal that feels both earned and appropriately heavy.
The emotional weight of the picture rests squarely on the shoulders of Gabe Nevins, who plays the protagonist, Alex. He delivers a quietly internalised performance that successfully anchors the film’s more abstract, drifting moments. However, I have to admit the supporting cast is a decidedly mixed bag. Some of the teenage side actors are genuinely, distractingly poor in their delivery. To be entirely fair, they are clearly non-professional actors pulled in for authenticity on a modest budget, but there are moments where their wooden line readings noticeably puncture the immersive bubble Van Sant is otherwise working so hard to maintain.
My lingering issue with the picture really crystallised the very next day, when I happened to watch Jonah Hill’s Mid90s. The comparison is almost unavoidable, and frankly, it doesn't do Van Sant’s film any favours. Where Mid90s captures the chaotic, messy, and authentic reality of youth culture with a sharp, lived-in edge, Paranoid Park can feel a touch too detached and self-consciously arthouse. It is as if Van Sant is observing the skaters through a thick, stylised pane of glass, whereas the later film invites you right into the bruised knees and bad decisions with far more naturalistic success.
This is a visually arresting, moody piece of cinema that gets several key elements very right, even if it stumbles a bit in the execution of its human dynamics. It is certainly not a bad film, but it occupies a frustrating middle ground: too stylised to feel completely raw, yet too grounded in its grim premise to be a purely abstract art piece. It remains a decent, atmospheric watch for those who appreciate slow-burn character studies, but it is comfortably overshadowed by superior entries in the same thematic lane.
Paranoid Park is the kind of film that tends to divide audiences fairly cleanly between those who find its elliptical, mood-first approach genuinely affecting and those who find it a little too pleased with its own restraint. It occupies a similar cultural space to Van Sant's earlier Elephant, in that it uses American adolescence as its setting while remaining somewhat at arm's length from the messy, lived-in reality of it. For viewers interested in how guilt and shock register in the body of a young person who has no framework for processing either, there is real value here. Those after something with a sharper, more propulsive sense of consequence might find themselves better served elsewhere, perhaps by something like It Follows, which uses a similarly dreamlike Portland-area atmosphere to rather more viscerally unsettling effect. At eighty-five minutes, Paranoid Park is at least committed enough not to outstay its welcome. It is a film you admire at a slight distance, which may, depending on your patience for arthouse restraint, be precisely the point or precisely the problem.
Rating: ★★★ | Year: 2007 | Watched: 2026-08-02
Trailer
▶ Watch the official trailer for Paranoid Park (2007) on YouTube
Where to watch
Watch in the UK
Stream: Amazon Prime Video · Amazon Prime Video with Ads
Rent: Amazon Video
Buy: Amazon Video
Physical: Amazon UK · Zavvi
Watch in the US
Physical: Amazon US
Affiliate disclosure: Movies With Macca may earn a small commission on purchases or subscriptions started via these links. It costs you nothing extra.
