Journey to Italy (1954)
There are films that arrive quietly and leave a long shadow. Roberto Rossellini's Journey to Italy, released in 1954, is one of those: a short, spare, almost plotless picture that critics largely dismissed on first release but which later generations of filmmakers treated as something close to a revelation. Jean-Luc Godard and François Truffaut championed it loudly, and its influence can be felt in the looser, more observational European cinema that followed through the late fifties and into the sixties. The French New Wave did not invent itself in a vacuum, and this film is one of the places you can trace the roots.
The premise is simple to the point of severity. An English couple, Katherine and Alex Joyce, drive south to Naples to arrange the sale of a villa inherited from a relative. The journey forces them into an unusual proximity, and what surfaces is the quiet, uncomfortable realisation that eight years of marriage have left them more or less strangers to one another. Rossellini co-wrote the script with the Sicilian novelist and screenwriter Vitaliano Brancati, though Brancati died the same year the film was released, and the finished picture bears the marks of Rossellini's characteristically loose, semi-improvisatory method. The production was a co-venture between several Italian and French companies, including Sveva Film and the Société Générale de Cinématographie, and it was made with the kind of modest resources that Rossellini had by then turned into something of a working principle. I also covered Germany, Year Zero (1948), an earlier Rossellini picture made in the bombed-out ruins of Berlin, which gives a useful sense of just how far his interests had shifted by the time he turned his camera on the sun-drenched landscapes of the Campania region.
The casting is, to put it mildly, freighted with real-world context. Ingrid Bergman plays Katherine, and George Sanders plays her husband Alex. Bergman was, at this point, Rossellini's actual partner and collaborator, a pairing that had scandalised the international press and effectively ended her Hollywood career for a period. Sanders, for his part, was a consummate screen presence with a particular gift for elegant detachment, the kind of actor who could suggest boredom and intelligence simultaneously (his Oscar-winning turn in All About Eve a few years earlier had cemented that reputation). Watching the two of them circle each other across eighty-five minutes, with the weight of the real relationship sitting just off screen, is an odd and not entirely comfortable experience. Maria Mauban, Anna Proclemer and Paul Müller appear in supporting roles, each adding texture to the Neapolitan world the Joyces move through without quite belonging to.
Visually, the film leans on the landscapes of southern Italy as something more than backdrop. Cinematographer Enzo Serafin shoots the ruins at Pompeii, the archaeological museum in Naples and the open roads of the region with a loose, documentary-adjacent quality, the kind of images that feel observed rather than composed, though Serafin's framing is consistently precise beneath that apparent casualness. The score was composed by Renzo Rossellini, the director's brother, and it sits lightly on the film, never pushing the emotional temperature but giving the quieter stretches a gentle, slightly melancholy colouring. Editor Jolanda Benvenuti's cutting is unhurried throughout, allowing scenes to breathe past the point where a more conventional picture might have moved on. That patience is entirely the point, and it is the quality that most divided audiences and critics at the time.
I came to Journey to Italy after watching a documentary about Roberto Rossellini and his turbulent relationship with Ingrid Bergman, and I suspect that coloured my experience of it more than anything else.
It made for an interesting watch, because you cannot help but read the one through the other. Knowing what I now knew about the pair of them, it was hard not to feel that some of their own offscreen feelings had bled into the film.
The film itself is a portrait of a marriage quietly coming apart. Katherine and Alex are a British couple who travel to Naples to sell an inherited villa and discover, more or less for the first time, that they barely know one another and may not much love one another either. There is a long stretch where Bergman's character does nothing but complain about men, and while the dialogue is fine and the whole thing holds the interest, I did find it a bit of a depressing sit.
Taken purely as a story, it is a muted, melancholy thing: two people who do not love each other, circling their own unhappiness in a beautiful setting. I can see that it is well made and that its quiet, drifting style was hugely influential, but I would be lying if I said I was swept up in it. What held me was the sense of actual lives pressing against the fiction, and without that documentary fresh in my mind I suspect it would have left me colder still. Three stars, an interesting, downbeat watch, more compelling for what sits behind it than for what plays out in front.
Journey to Italy is one of those films that lives differently depending on what you bring to it. Stripped of biographical context, it is a polished but unremarkable study in marital estrangement, set against scenery that Italy has never had any shortage of. Loaded with context, it becomes something stranger and more alive, the kind of film where the gap between what is being performed and what is actually being felt becomes the real subject. For a companion piece on a film where atmosphere and European setting do much of the heavy lifting, see also my thoughts on These Encounters of Theirs (2006), which treads related ground in a very different register. And for another 1954 release that occupies a very different but equally contested place in the canon, I wrote about On the Waterfront not long ago. Journey to Italy rewards patience and prior reading in roughly equal measure. Whether it rewards the uninitiated viewer on its own terms is, as the review above suggests, rather less certain.
Rating: ★★★ | Year: 1954 | Watched: 2026-10-17
Trailer
▶ Watch the official trailer for Journey to Italy (1954) on YouTube
Where to watch
Watch in the UK
Stream: BFI Player · BFI Player Amazon Channel · BFI Player Apple TV Channel
Rent: Apple TV Store
Buy: Apple TV Store
Physical: Amazon UK · Zavvi
Watch in the US
Stream: HBO Max Amazon Channel · Criterion Channel · HBO Max
Rent: Amazon Video · Apple TV Store · Fandango At Home
Buy: Amazon Video · Apple TV Store · Fandango At Home
Physical: Amazon US
Affiliate disclosure: Movies With Macca may earn a small commission on purchases or subscriptions started via these links. It costs you nothing extra.
