Fishing Without Nets (2014)
Somali piracy became one of the defining news stories of the late 2000s and early 2010s, filling broadsheet column inches and television bulletins with images of armed men on skiffs, ransomed supertankers, and naval patrols in the Gulf of Aden. Hollywood's response was largely to frame it as an action-thriller problem with an action-thriller solution, as Paul Greengrass demonstrated with Captain Phillips in 2013. But the reality off the Somali coast was rooted in something far less cinematic: decades of state collapse, the destruction of traditional fishing livelihoods by illegal foreign trawlers, and a generation of young men with very few options left. It is that quieter, more uncomfortable truth that Fishing Without Nets aims to put on screen, and for context it is worth noting that this is not a lone entry in the field. If you want a more documentary-minded companion piece, Macca's review of Stolen Seas covers the 2013 non-fiction treatment of the same crisis, and the two make a worthwhile double bill for anyone trying to understand how the problem looked from the inside.
The film began as a short, which won the narrative short prize at Sundance in 2012, before director Cutter Hodierne expanded it to feature length. Hodierne came up largely through documentary and commercial work, and that background is legible throughout: the production has a lean, observational texture that distinguishes it from more polished but unremarkable prestige efforts. Backing came from VICE Media and Think Media Studios, which placed it firmly in the independent space, though the American infrastructure behind it gave the project resources that most films shot in this part of the world simply do not have access to. The production filmed on location in Kenya, standing in for the Somali coastline, and the physical environment ends up being one of the film's most persuasive elements. Elsewhere in East African cinema, a film like Nairobi Half Life demonstrated what committed local filmmaking in the region can achieve on a fraction of the budget, and it is an instructive comparison.
The lead, Abdikani Muktar, carries the film on his shoulders as Abdi, the young fisherman whose family circumstances push him toward piracy. Muktar was not a professional actor at the time of filming, and there is a rawness to the performance that suits the material. Alongside him, Abdi Siad and Abduwhali Faarah fill out the crew of pirates with credible, unglamourised work. French actor Reda Kateb, who by this point had already drawn considerable attention for his role in A Prophet, appears as one of the tanker's hostages, and his presence gives the film a slightly different register in those scenes, a European art-house quality that sits in interesting tension with the rougher energy around him. Idil Ibrahim rounds out the principal cast in the role of Abdi's wife, providing the domestic anchor that the film returns to across its 109-minute runtime.
By the time the first skiff hits the water in Cutter Hodierne’s 2014 drama Fishing Without Nets, I was already fighting off a severe case of déjà vu. This is roughly the fourth film I’ve sat through that attempts to tackle the Somali piracy phenomenon, and while the geopolitical reality is undeniably complex, the cinematic well is starting to feel a bit dry.
The premise follows a desperate local fisherman who turns to hijacking cargo ships to feed his family, painting an absolutely harrowing picture of life on the Horn of Africa. It’s a heavy, vital subject, but the execution leans heavily into a rather predictable "good guy does bad things for a noble cause" trajectory. You can see the moral compromises coming a mile off, which robs the narrative of any real suspense.
That being said, you have to give fair play to the technical team. Despite being an independent project, it is technically an American production, and it absolutely shows on screen. The picture is remarkably well-produced visually, capturing the stark, sun-baked desperation of the Somali coastline with a striking, almost documentary-like clarity. The cinematography does a brilliant job of grounding the high-stakes maritime action in a very tangible reality.
When the film focuses on the sheer, grinding poverty that forces these men onto the water in the first place, it manages to be genuinely affecting, reminding you that behind the headlines of international crime are real, desperate human beings.
However, a cracking visual palette can only carry a film so far when the script is playing it this safe. The character arcs are firmly locked into their respective lanes, and the moral dilemmas are telegraphed with a heavy hand. We know exactly who is going to crack under pressure and who is going to hold onto their humanity, making the third act feel less like a thrilling escalation and more like a checklist of expected tropes. It’s a bit of a shame, really, because the raw material is ripe for a truly subversive or unpredictable take, but Hodierne opts for a comfortable, conventional drama instead.
Fishing Without Nets is a decent piece of cinema that succeeds more as a visual mood piece than a groundbreaking narrative. It’s a well-intentioned and sheds necessary light on a tragic situation, even if it doesn't quite break new ground in how that story is told.
Cutter Hodierne has crafted a solid, competent film that is certainly worth your time if you have an interest in the region, but it remains firmly in the realm of good, not great.
Fishing Without Nets sits in a particular category of well-meaning independent cinema: the kind that earns genuine respect for the seriousness of its ambitions and the rigour of its visual craft, while falling just short of the narrative courage those ambitions demand. It is a film that trusts its setting more than its story. For viewers with a broader interest in how cinema engages with crisis and displacement in East Africa, it remains a worthwhile stop on a longer journey. That journey might also take in The Last Tourist, which looks at the region from a very different angle. Hodierne made something honest here, and honesty counts for something. It just does not always count for enough.
Rating: ★★★ | Year: 2014 | Watched: 2026-07-15
Where to watch
Watch in the UK
Rent: Google Play Movies · YouTube
Buy: Google Play Movies · YouTube
Physical: Amazon UK · Zavvi
Watch in the US
Buy: Apple TV Store
Physical: Amazon US
Affiliate disclosure: Movies With Macca may earn a small commission on purchases or subscriptions started via these links. It costs you nothing extra.
