Titicut Follies (1967)
Some films you admire more than you enjoy, and some films you respect more than you admire. Titicut Follies sits somewhere in that uncomfortable second category, and I've been turning it over in my head ever since the credits rolled, not because it moved me in any clean or satisfying way, but because it refuses to let you off the hook.
Frederick Wiseman's 1967 documentary is a fly-on-the-wall record of a Massachusetts institution for men deemed criminally insane. There is no narrator, no music, no on-screen text explaining what you're seeing or who these people are. The camera simply watches: men stripped naked, force-fed through tubes, spoken to with casual contempt by the staff meant to care for them, denied every last scrap of privacy or dignity. As a record of institutional cruelty, it is eye-opening in the most brutal sense. It is little surprise that it was banned in the United States for decades, officially on privacy grounds, though it is very hard not to suspect that a film making the authorities look this catastrophically bad was never going to be welcomed with open arms.
And yet. And yet the very thing that gives the film its power is also the thing that most unsettles me, and not in the way Wiseman intends. These are men who, in many cases, could almost certainly not have given any meaningful consent to being filmed. The camera does not spare them. There is full-frontal nudity of people who, I strongly suspect, had little grasp of what was happening or why. A fair warning about distressing content doesn't entirely dissolve that unease. There's a real ethical knot here: the film exposes an injustice by, arguably, committing a smaller one against the very people it's trying to speak for. I don't think there's an easy answer to that, and it is genuinely to the film's credit that it plants you in the discomfort and leaves you sitting there.
Where it falls down for me is as documentary craft, or at least as a particular kind of documentary craft I find most illuminating. This is pure, unmediated observation, raw footage with absolutely no framing. That has undeniable force, but it also means no questions are asked, no context is offered, no attempt is made to help you understand the system that produced what you're seeing. I've reviewed Time on here before, a documentary that also takes a hard, unflinching look at institutional failure, but which builds something around its footage, gives you a way in. Wiseman just points the camera and leaves you to it. And for all the raw power of that approach, I came away feeling I had been shown a great deal and helped to understand rather little. I know what I witnessed. I couldn't fully tell you why it was allowed to happen, who was responsible, what came of it. The film isn't interested in those questions.
That isn't automatically a flaw. Some documentaries are pure testimony, and testimony has its own value. But I think there's a version of this subject that could have been both morally rigorous and more illuminating, one that doesn't sacrifice the shock of the footage but also trusts the audience enough to give them something to think with, not just something to recoil from. As it stands, it's closer to an endurance than an experience.
Three stars, then, and I mean that honestly rather than dismissively. This is a landmark film, an important film, a deeply uncomfortable one. I found it more important than I found it good, essential in its way, and not something I ever much want to sit through again. If you can stomach it, you probably should see it. Just don't expect it to hold your hand, or to feel anything like resolved when it's done.
Rating: ★★★ | Year: 1967 | Watched: 2026-09-03
Where to watch
Watch in the UK
Stream: BFI Player · BFI Player Amazon Channel · BFI Player Apple TV Channel
Rent: Apple TV Store · Amazon Video
Buy: Apple TV Store · Amazon Video
Physical: Amazon UK · Zavvi
Watch in the US
Physical: Amazon US
Affiliate disclosure: Movies With Macca may earn a small commission on purchases or subscriptions started via these links. It costs you nothing extra.
