The Purple Rose of Cairo (1985)
There is a lovely, wistful idea sitting at the heart of The Purple Rose of Cairo, and for a good while it is enough. Woody Allen's 1985 film follows Cecilia, a downtrodden waitress in Depression-era New Jersey, played by Mia Farrow, who escapes her miserable reality the only way she knows how: by losing herself in the pictures. She watches the same film over and over again, until one day a character steps down from the screen and into her world. It is a genuinely beautiful premise, the sort of thing that makes you sit up and think: yes, of course, why hasn't someone done this before?
Well, someone had, sort of. If the high concept sounds familiar, it is worth noting that Allen got there a good eight years ahead of Last Action Hero. But where that film played the idea as blockbuster spectacle, this comes at it from a far gentler, more melancholy angle. It is less interested in the comedy of a fictional man loose in the real world, and more in what it says about loneliness, longing and the dangerous comfort of stories. That is a richer seam to mine, and at its best the film mines it beautifully.
There is real sweetness in Cecilia's starstruck romance with a dashing figure who is, quite literally, too good and too fictional to be true. He does not lie, does not cheat, does not disappoint. He is every leading man she has ever watched from the dark of the stalls, made flesh. And the film has some proper fun with the chaos left behind: a supporting cast stranded mid-scene, a studio in a panic, a leading man gone missing from his own movie. These are the moments where Allen's comic instincts and his more tender impulses are working together, and it is a pleasure to watch.
The trouble is that a premise this delicate can only carry you so far. Even at a trim eighty-two minutes, it starts to feel stretched. The central conceit is charming but slight, and the film runs out of places to take it well before the credits roll. Any longer and it would have been in real bother. The idea is doing the heavy lifting, and when you ask it to carry the weight of a full feature it begins to buckle just a little. Not catastrophically. But enough that you notice.
Which is why I came away thinking this might have made a wonderful short. As a fifteen or twenty minute fable about cinema and escape, about the gap between the lives we live and the ones we watch, it could have been close to perfect. As an eighty-minute feature it is pleasant, warm and wry, and I liked it more than not, but it is also a touch thin. The idea has rather outpaced the story built around it.
Mia Farrow is genuinely lovely in it, bringing a fragility to Cecilia that keeps you on her side even when the film itself is not quite sure where to take her. And Allen, as a director, keeps things light-footed and visually unpretentious throughout. This is not the kind of lush, romantic New York he conjured in Manhattan (1979), but it has its own modest, Depression-greys aesthetic that suits the material well.
It is not a bad film at all. It is warm, clever, nicely made and genuinely affecting in places. But it is not one that especially stayed with me once the lights came up. I kept thinking about what it could have been with a sharper edit or a tighter focus, and that slight nagging feeling is hard to shake. A charming curio. A better idea than it is a film. Three stars.
Rating: ★★★ | Year: 1985 | Watched: 2026-08-29
Where to watch
Watch in the UK
Rent: Apple TV Store · Amazon Video · Google Play Movies · Sky Store
Buy: Apple TV Store · Amazon Video · Google Play Movies · Sky Store
Physical: Amazon UK · Zavvi
Watch in the US
Rent: Amazon Video · Apple TV Store · Google Play Movies · YouTube
Buy: Amazon Video · Apple TV Store · Google Play Movies · YouTube
Physical: Amazon US
Affiliate disclosure: Movies With Macca may earn a small commission on purchases or subscriptions started via these links. It costs you nothing extra.
