On the Count of Three (2021)

Share
On the Count of Three (2021)

On the Count of Three arrived at the Sundance Film Festival in January 2021, where it had its world premiere as Jerrod Carmichael's debut feature as director. It is a film that earns its place in a particular, uncomfortable tradition: the dark comedy that treats mental health not as a backdrop but as its entire subject. The premise is not for the faint-hearted. Two best friends, both having reached the point where they cannot see a way forward, make a pact to end their lives together, and decide to spend whatever time remains settling old scores and finishing unfinished business. It is the kind of pitch that can clear a room, and the fact that Sundance received it at all says something about the appetite for films willing to go to these places without softening the edges. That tagline, "It's a great day to be alive," does most of the tonal work in four words.

Carmichael, best known up to that point as a stand-up comedian and the creator and star of the semi-autobiographical NBC sitcom The Carmichael Show, took on the script by Ari Katcher and Ryan Welch and chose to put himself in front of the camera as well as behind it. He plays Val, the friend whose despair sets the whole machinery in motion, opposite Christopher Abbott as Kevin, the friend he recruits from a psychiatric facility. Abbott had been building a reputation for choosing difficult, physically committed work in films such as Possessor and It Comes at Night, and he brings that same willingness to exist in uncomfortable silences to this role. Rounding out the main cast are Tiffany Haddish, Lavell Crawford, and JB Smoove, names that signal the comedy pedigree Carmichael was drawing on even as the material pushes in a far darker direction. The production brought together Valparaiso Pictures, Werner Entertainment, Morningside Entertainment, and Front Porch Pictures, and the film carries the kind of lean, unfussy quality that tends to come from a production without significant studio money behind it.

Cinematographer Marshall Adams, who worked extensively with Carmichael on The Carmichael Show, shoots the film in a way that feels close and a little restless, keeping the camera near the two men rather than pulling back to aestheticise their situation. The palette is neither grim nor glossy, sitting somewhere in the ordinary daylight of a nondescript American town, which is part of the point. Composer Owen Pallett, the Canadian composer and violinist who has collaborated with artists ranging from Arcade Fire to Frank Ocean, provides a score that leans into strings without ever becoming mournful in an obvious way, holding back from the emotional underlining that a less controlled approach might have gone for. Editor Tom Eagles keeps things moving through an 86-minute runtime that never outstays its welcome even when the tonal balance is under strain. For another film from 2021 doing something tonally ambitious in a very different key, I also reviewed Licorice Pizza around the same time. And for a film that similarly wrestles with darkness and violence through an uncomfortable comic register, see also my thoughts on Is God Is.

I came away from On the Count of Three thinking it profoundly average, which feels like a strange verdict on a film reaching for something this raw.

The setup is bleak and bold: two lifelong friends, both at the end of their tether, make a pact to end their lives together, and spend one last day tying up loose ends before they do. It is heavy, difficult material, handled without flinching, and yet for all that I struggled to stay connected to the two men at its centre.

It is pitched, I gather, as a dark comedy, finding grim laughs in a grim situation, but almost none of that humour landed for me. The tone is a tricky one to strike, and the film too often left me neither moved nor amused, just watching from a distance. It did not help that I found it fairly predictable, able to see where each strand was heading well before it got there, which drains a story like this of the tension it badly needs.

There is clear craft in the writing, mind. The dialogue is decent, and the two central characters are developed with care, so that you understand them even when you cannot quite feel for them.

It is also, I would guess, made on a slim budget, and to its credit it never looks cheap so much as spare. Three stars. A bleak, well-meant and reasonably well-made film about a desperately heavy subject, let down for me by humour that misfired and a story I could see coming.

On the Count of Three is not an easy film to place in a conversation, which might be part of its problem and part of its appeal in equal measure. It sits at an awkward angle to both comedy and drama, unwilling to commit fully to either, and the people who respond to it tend to be the ones who find that very resistance interesting rather than frustrating. Carmichael went on to make The Inspection and the semi-autobiographical Rothaniel special, both of which suggested a filmmaker and performer still working out how much of himself to put into a room before the atmosphere changes. Whether you consider this debut a promising rough cut or a missed opportunity rather depends on how much the humour connects, and that is a more personal calculation than most. A film that reaches for something real and lands somewhere in the vicinity, which in this particular territory is, at the very least, no small thing.


Rating: ★★★ | Year: 2021 | Watched: 2026-10-19

View on Letterboxd →


Trailer

▶ Watch the official trailer for On the Count of Three (2021) on YouTube


Where to watch

Watch in the UK
Rent:
Apple TV Store · Amazon Video
Buy: Apple TV Store · Amazon Video
Physical: Amazon UK · Zavvi

Watch in the US
Stream:
Amazon Prime Video · Amazon Prime Video with Ads
Rent: Amazon Video · Apple TV Store · Google Play Movies · YouTube
Buy: Amazon Video · Apple TV Store · Google Play Movies · YouTube
Physical: Amazon US

Affiliate disclosure: Movies With Macca may earn a small commission on purchases or subscriptions started via these links. It costs you nothing extra.

Film images and data courtesy of TMDB. This product uses the TMDB API but is not endorsed or certified by TMDB.