1917 (2019)
There's a moment in 1917 where a soldier sprints through a ruined town lit only by drifting flares, buildings crumbling around him, figures emerging from the dark, the whole world reduced to noise and shadow and the desperate pump of legs. It lasts just a few minutes, but it feels like a lifetime. That's the trick Sam Mendes pulls off across the entire film: collapsing the distance between audience and screen until there's no screen left. You're not watching these two young men run. You're running with them.
The conceit, the film shot to play out as two continuous, unbroken takes, could easily have felt like a gimmick. It doesn't. In Roger Deakins' hands it becomes something else entirely: a sustained act of empathy. The camera stays close, shoulder-to-shoulder with the soldiers, and that intimacy means you feel every stumble, every held breath, every moment of terrifying stillness. Deakins wraps the whole thing in mud and smoke and, occasionally, something unexpectedly beautiful. A cherry blossom grove drifting petals over devastation. A burning building reflected in still water. These images don't soften what war is. They make the contrast more brutal.
George MacKay and Dean-Charles Chapman anchor all of this with performances that never overreach. They're exhausted, frightened, determined, ordinary. That ordinariness is the whole point. This isn't heroic mythmaking with its chest out. It's something quieter and more honest: a portrait of two men putting one foot in front of the other because there's no other choice. The supporting cast, glimpsed briefly as the mission pushes forward, adds texture without stealing focus.
The set pieces are outstanding without exception. The flare-lit sprint I mentioned already, but there's also a tense, almost unbearably quiet encounter in a bombed-out farmhouse, and several moments where sudden, casual violence cuts through the film like a cold shock. 1917 never sanitises the trenches. The rats, the mud, the smell you can almost imagine, the psychological weight of what these men have already seen and what they're walking towards. It's unflinching in the way the best war films are: not to shock, but to bear witness. It reminded me, in spirit if not in form, of the unblinking documentary horror in Lessons of Darkness, that sense that some human catastrophes simply have to be looked at directly.
If I've got a gripe, it's with Thomas Newman's score. It's competent, it does what it needs to do, but it falls short of his best work. In a film this precisely crafted, music that merely functions rather than resonates is noticeable by comparison. And yes, the premise is simple: two soldiers, a message, a clock ticking. You always know roughly where this is going. But that predictability isn't a weakness. It's the design. The power of 1917 lives entirely in execution, in the weight Mendes and Deakins load onto every frame, every step, every breath. The destination matters less than what it costs to get there.
What stays with me isn't any single scene but the cumulative pressure of the thing. The way tension is never released, only briefly eased before it tightens again. The way the film trusts silence. The way it earns its final image without forcing sentiment. Mendes, perhaps best known on this blog for his Bond work (I've written about Skyfall and its messier follow-up Spectre), is operating on a completely different level here. This is the film that will define his legacy.
Four stars. A modern war classic that earns every ounce of its acclaim, and one of the finest pieces of sustained filmmaking I've seen in years.
Rating: ★★★★ | Year: 2019 | Watched: 2026-05-20
Where to watch
Watch in the UK
Stream: Netflix · Netflix Standard with Ads
Rent: Apple TV Store · Amazon Video · Google Play Movies · Sky Store
Buy: Apple TV Store · Amazon Video · Google Play Movies · Sky Store
Physical: Amazon UK · Zavvi
Watch in the US
Stream: Netflix · Netflix Standard with Ads
Rent: Amazon Video · Apple TV Store · Google Play Movies · YouTube
Buy: Amazon Video · Apple TV Store · Google Play Movies · YouTube
Physical: Amazon US
Affiliate disclosure: Movies With Macca may earn a small commission on purchases or subscriptions started via these links. It costs you nothing extra.
