The Rum Diary (2011)
There's a specific, sun-drenched haze to Bruce Robinson's adaptation of Hunter S. Thompson's The Rum Diary, and unfortunately it mostly just obscures a deeply average film. You sit there watching the warm Puerto Rican light bounce off rum bottles and white beaches, and part of you thinks: this should be electric. Thompson's source material practically begs for a wilder, more unhinged translation. What you get instead is something that feels frustratingly safe, like someone filed the edges off a machete and handed you a butter knife.
The film clearly wants to be a sharp, gonzo commentary on the decay of journalism and the creeping rot of American capitalism. Those ambitions are visible throughout, lurking just beneath the surface. But somewhere in the journey from page to screen, the script gets entirely too Hollywoodised. The chaos gets managed. The madness gets contained. What should feel like a fever dream feels instead like a very expensive, very pretty holiday brochure with occasional monologues about the corruption of the American dream dropped in between cocktail hours.
Johnny Depp, to his credit, actually does a really good job here. He captures that specific blend of weary cynicism and manic energy that suits this kind of material, and there are moments where you can see the film it could have been flickering behind his eyes. Fair play also to Giovanni Ribisi, who brings a cracking, jittery nervous energy to his role and holds his own admirably against whatever the script throws at him. He's one of those actors who makes you wish the camera followed him a bit more. It's worth saying that this is a very different Depp to the one I remember watching in Donnie Brasco (1997), where he had tight, grounded material to anchor him. Here he's clearly capable, but the film around him keeps letting him drift.
Then there's Amber Heard. Look, I'll acknowledge the obvious: knowing what we know now makes her casting feel inherently awkward, and it's difficult to separate the performance from everything that came after. But setting all of that aside as best I can, the performance is genuinely wooden. She struggles to find any natural rhythm in her scenes, and because the script already gives her character so little depth or spark to work with, those scenes just sit there, airless and inert.
The fundamental problem is that the film never quite decides what it wants to be. It flits between drunken slapstick, romantic longing, and pseudo-intellectual musings without ever fully committing to any of them. The pacing drags its feet through long, dialogue-heavy sequences that feel more like a rehearsal than a finished product. You keep waiting for that Thompson madness to truly ignite, for Robinson to throw the wheel and let the whole thing go gloriously off-road. He never does. He keeps it frustratingly tidy, and tidiness is absolutely the last thing this story needed.
There's a version of this film that's genuinely great. The ingredients are there: a fascinating setting, a rich source text, a lead actor well-suited to the material. But a ruthless editor and a willingness to truly embrace the gonzo spirit were apparently not on the production's shopping list. Instead we get something that meanders aimlessly across those gorgeous beaches without ever finding its footing.
Two and a half stars. The Rum Diary is a perfectly decent watch if you've got a rainy afternoon to fill and nothing better on, but it lacks the teeth of a true satire and the heart of a genuine character study. It's a harmless, mildly entertaining diversion, and for a story rooted in Thompson's restless, furious brilliance, "harmless" might just be the most damning thing you can say about it.
Rating: ★★½ | Year: 2011 | Watched: 2026-07-31
Where to watch
Watch in the UK
Rent: Apple TV Store · Rakuten TV · Google Play Movies · YouTube
Buy: Apple TV Store · Rakuten TV · Google Play Movies · YouTube
Physical: Amazon UK · Zavvi
Watch in the US
Rent: Amazon Video · Apple TV Store · Google Play Movies · YouTube
Buy: Amazon Video · Apple TV Store · Google Play Movies · YouTube
Physical: Amazon US
Affiliate disclosure: Movies With Macca may earn a small commission on purchases or subscriptions started via these links. It costs you nothing extra.
