The Rum Diary (2011)
Hunter S. Thompson spent the better part of four decades trying to get The Rum Diary published. He wrote the novel in the early 1960s, drawing on his time as a young freelance journalist in Puerto Rico, but the manuscript sat in a drawer until Johnny Depp, a close friend of Thompson's, reportedly discovered it while helping to sort through the author's belongings and pushed for its release. It finally reached bookshops in 1998, and the film adaptation followed thirteen years after that, arriving just six years after Thompson's death in 2005. That long, winding road to the screen gives the project a certain sentimental weight, even if the finished product doesn't quite honour the effort it took to get there. The story centres on Paul Kemp, an American journalist who fetches up in San Juan to write for a struggling local newspaper, and finds himself drinking heavily, eyeing up a business associate's girlfriend, and growing increasingly uneasy about the property developers busily carving up the island for profit. It is, at its bones, a story about a man searching for something to be angry about, and finding it.
Bruce Robinson is an interesting choice to shepherd this material. British writer-directors don't come much more singular than Robinson, whose debut feature Withnail and I (1987) is essentially a national institution at this point, a film about dissolution, failed ambition, and the end of youth that has aged into something genuinely beloved. He largely stepped away from directing after the troubled production of Jennifer Eight in 1992, making The Rum Diary his return after nearly two decades away from the camera. On paper, a man who wrote Withnail adapting a Thompson novel about rum-soaked journalistic disillusionment sounds like a natural fit, and you can see why the project appealed to him. The film was produced through a combination of smaller outfits, including Depp's own Infinitum Nihil banner, which signals just how personally invested the lead actor was in seeing it made. Depp, of course, had already played Thompson's alter ego Raoul Duke in Terry Gilliam's Fear and Loathing in Las Vegas back in 1998, and it's worth checking out our thoughts on some of his other work of this era, including Once Upon a Time in Mexico (2003) and Pirates of the Caribbean: On Stranger Tides (2011), which came out the same year as this film. By 2011, Depp was operating at the height of his commercial pull, though some critics were already beginning to wonder whether the quirkier, more personal projects were landing as well as the blockbusters.
The supporting cast is, on balance, a polished but unremarkable collection of reliable faces. Aaron Eckhart plays the smooth, morally flexible businessman with the easy confidence you'd expect from him, and Michael Rispoli brings a warm, lived-in energy as Kemp's colleague and companion. Giovanni Ribisi, in a role quite removed from his more straightforward work elsewhere, leans into something stranger and more unsettled. Amber Heard, then relatively early in her career, takes on the role of the woman caught between Kemp and Eckhart's developer, a part that asks her to be magnetic enough to plausibly derail a man's entire sense of purpose. The Puerto Rican locations were shot with obvious care, giving the film a warm, sun-bleached visual texture that at least gives the eyes something to appreciate while the story does its wandering. For a broader sense of how Depp fares when the material around him is sharper and the direction more assured, our review of Donnie Brasco (1997) makes for useful comparison.
There is a specific, sun-drenched haze to Bruce Robinson’s 2011 adaptation of Hunter S. Thompson’s The Rum Diary, but unfortunately, it mostly just obscures a deeply average film.
I found the whole picture to be frustratingly rambling, meandering aimlessly across the beaches of 1960s Puerto Rico without ever finding its footing. It is clearly aiming for a sharp, gonzo commentary on the decay of journalism and the creeping rot of American capitalism, but somewhere along the line, the script gets entirely too Hollywoodised. Instead of a biting, chaotic satire, we are left with an overly polished travelogue that desperately needed a ruthless editor to trim the fat.
The cast does their absolute best with the material they are handed. Johnny Depp, as espected, actually does a really good job here, capturing that specific blend of weary cynicism and manic energy he always brings to these roles. Fair play to Giovanni Ribisi, who brings a cracking, nervous energy and holds his own admirably. However, it is impossible to ignore the presence of Amber Heard. Knowing what we know now makes her casting inherently awkward, but setting that aside, her performance is genuinely wooden. She struggles to find any natural rhythm in her scenes, which only highlights the script's inability to give its characters any real depth or spark.
The fundamental issue is that the film never quite decides what it wants to be. It flits between drunken slapstick, romantic longing, and pseudo-intellectual musings without ever fully committing to any of them. The pacing is a bit of a puzzle, dragging its feet through long, dialogue-heavy sequences that feel more like a rehearsal than a finished product. You keep waiting for that Thompson madness to truly ignite, but Robinson keeps the whole affair frustratingly safe and contained. It is a shame, really, because the source material practically begs for a wilder, more unhinged cinematic translation.
The Rum Diary is a perfectly decent watch if you have nothing better to do on a rainy afternoon, but it is certainly nothing special or noteworthy. It lacks the teeth of a true satire and the heart of a genuine character study, leaving you with a film that is just sort of... there. It is a harmless, mildly entertaining diversion that fails to live up to the legacy of its author.
Taken as a whole, The Rum Diary sits in that particular category of films that arrive with genuine pedigree and genuine affection behind them, and yet somehow produce something less than the sum of their parts. Thompson's reputation, Robinson's history, Depp's commitment, and a setting that practically radiates atmosphere: all of it is present, and none of it quite coheres into anything with real bite. For viewers curious about where this fits in the broader arc of Depp's career choices, or simply interested in how literary adaptations can go politely, inoffensively wrong, it remains a watchable enough curio. Just don't go in expecting the madness. The rum is watered down.
Rating: ★★½ | Year: 2011 | Watched: 2026-07-31
Trailer
▶ Watch the official trailer for The Rum Diary (2011) on YouTube
Where to watch
Watch in the UK
Rent: Apple TV Store · Rakuten TV · Google Play Movies · YouTube
Buy: Apple TV Store · Rakuten TV · Google Play Movies · YouTube
Physical: Amazon UK · Zavvi
Watch in the US
Rent: Amazon Video · Apple TV Store · Google Play Movies · YouTube
Buy: Amazon Video · Apple TV Store · Google Play Movies · YouTube
Physical: Amazon US
Affiliate disclosure: Movies With Macca may earn a small commission on purchases or subscriptions started via these links. It costs you nothing extra.
