The Emperor's New Groove (2000)
By the turn of the millennium, Walt Disney Feature Animation found itself at a crossroads it had been approaching for some years. The so-called Disney Renaissance of the late eighties and nineties, that remarkable run from The Little Mermaid through to Mulan, had produced a string of films that felt genuinely ambitious, films that married spectacle with emotional weight and pulled in audiences of all ages. By 2000, however, the wind had shifted. Pixar's computer-generated features were drawing the crowds and the critical plaudits, and Disney's own traditionally animated output was beginning to feel, in some quarters, like a format looking for a reason to persist. The Emperor's New Groove arrived into that climate: a relatively modest, 78-minute comedy set loosely against a pre-Columbian Andean backdrop, making no particular claims to historical accuracy and wearing its silliness as a badge of honour rather than an apology. It is worth noting that the film had a notoriously troubled production, originally conceived as a far more earnest musical called Kingdom of the Sun before being substantially reimagined into the broad comedy that reached cinemas. That behind-the-scenes chaos is, in itself, something of a minor legend among animation enthusiasts.
The film was directed by Mark Dindal, whose previous feature credit was the modestly received Cats Don't Dance (1997), and it was produced under the Walt Disney Pictures banner with a budget that, while not released officially, was understood to be considerably lower than the studio's prestige productions of the preceding decade. The source material, such as it is, owes more to classic cartoon tradition and farce than to any literary or folkloric origin, which perhaps explains both the film's anarchic energy and its structural looseness. For those curious about how Disney's more considered animated output compared during this general period, Macca's thoughts on A Goofy Movie offer an interesting point of reference, covering another Disney title that sat somewhat outside the studio's main prestige line. The question of what makes family animation genuinely work across age groups is also something Macca addressed in his look at Monsters, Inc., a film released just a year after this one that arrived at very different answers.
The voice cast assembled here is, on paper, a genuinely attractive proposition. David Spade, then best known for his deadpan, slightly self-satisfied comic persona from his Saturday Night Live years and a string of film comedies, voices the spoilt Emperor Kuzco. John Goodman, an actor whose warmth and comic timing are practically a force of nature, plays Pacha, the good-natured villager reluctantly dragged into Kuzco's chaos. Eartha Kitt, bringing unmistakable theatrical menace, voices the scheming Yzma, and Patrick Warburton, a man whose voice seems purpose-built for dimwitted confidence, plays her henchman Kronk. Wendie Malick rounds out the principal cast as Yzma's long-suffering associate. The combination of Spade's sardonic edge with Goodman's warmth is a reasonable comic pairing on paper, and Kitt in particular seems to relish every line she delivers. Whether the material gives any of them enough to genuinely work with is, of course, the more pointed question. Fans of a certain strain of early 2000s comedy, the kind of irreverent, pop-culture-adjacent humour that also powered something like Zoolander, may find themselves on familiar, if not always satisfying, ground.
There’s a very specific, nostalgic charm to the final gasps of traditional 2D animation at Disney, right before the studio completely surrendered to the CGI takeover.
Mark Dindal’s 2000 feature The Emperor’s New Groove sits right in that transitional sweet spot, and I’ll happily concede that the animation is genuinely good. The art style is bright, snappy, and undeniably nice to look at, offering a cracking visual showcase of what the old-school ink-and-paint departments could still pull off when given a slightly more exaggerated, cartoonish canvas.
But looking pretty doesn't automatically make it a classic. For all its visual flair, the film is nowhere near the best of the Disney canon; in fact, it’s largely forgettable the moment the credits roll. You’ve got a genuinely cracking voice cast on paper, with David Spade bringing his trademark sarcastic whine to the titular llama, backed up by the reliably brilliant John Goodman, Eartha Kitt, and Patrick Warburton. Yet, even their combined comedic talents can’t entirely mask the fact that the script is just a bit of a mess of recycled sitcom tropes and slapstick gags that fail to leave any lasting impression.
The real issue here is the target audience, or rather, the lack of crossover appeal. It’s a perfectly average kids' film and absolutely nothing more. I found that while the frantic pacing and loud noises will undoubtedly keep the younger viewers thoroughly entertained, it offers pretty much nothing for the adults sitting next to them on the sofa. There’s no underlying emotional depth, no clever subtext, and certainly none of that razor-sharp, dual-layered writing that made the studio's 90s renaissance so special. It’s just surface-level silliness from start to finish.
Strip away the bright colours and the frantic pacing, and you're left with a harmless, easily digestible distraction that does exactly what it needs to do to pass the time on a rainy afternoon. Dindal crafted a highly functional, visually pleasing piece of children's entertainment, but it completely lacks the magic, heart, or narrative brilliance required to elevate it above mere mediocrity. It’s a thoroughly forgettable watch for anyone over the age of ten.
The Emperor's New Groove is the kind of film that tends to produce a split in the room: those who encountered it as children and carry genuine warmth for it, and those coming to it fresh who find it polished but unremarkable, a film that executes its modest ambitions competently without ever suggesting it had larger ones. It occupies an odd space in the Disney catalogue, neither a celebrated classic nor quite the forgotten misfire its production troubles might suggest it deserved to be. What it does confirm, perhaps, is that a strong voice cast and confident visual craft are necessary ingredients for animation but not, on their own, sufficient ones. Sometimes a film knows exactly what it is, and the honest question is simply whether that is enough. On a rainy afternoon, perhaps. On reflection, probably not.
Rating: ★★½ | Year: 2000 | Watched: 2026-07-23
Trailer
▶ Watch the official trailer for The Emperor's New Groove (2000) on YouTube
Where to watch
Watch in the UK
Stream: Disney Plus
Rent: Rakuten TV
Buy: Apple TV Store · Rakuten TV · Amazon Video · Google Play Movies
Physical: Amazon UK · Zavvi
Watch in the US
Stream: Disney Plus
Rent: Amazon Video · Apple TV Store · Google Play Movies · YouTube
Buy: Amazon Video · Apple TV Store · Google Play Movies · YouTube
Physical: Amazon US
Affiliate disclosure: Movies With Macca may earn a small commission on purchases or subscriptions started via these links. It costs you nothing extra.
