Fist Fight (2017)
There is something almost reassuringly old-fashioned about the premise of Fist Fight. Two teachers, one provocation, one parking lot, four o'clock. It is the kind of high-concept setup that could have been scrawled on a napkin in a writers' room circa 1985, and in many respects the film that surrounds it feels exactly that vintage: a broad, loud, raucously juvenile comedy that plants its flag firmly in the tradition of Police Academy and never really tries to move beyond it. Released in February 2017 by New Line Cinema and Village Roadshow Pictures, with 21 Laps Entertainment and RatPac Entertainment among the production partners, it arrives wearing its intentions openly. The tagline tells you everything: "After school. Parking lot. It's on." That is the film. That is almost all the film.
Behind the camera is Richie Keen, a television director whose credits include long runs on It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia, which explains some of the stylistic DNA here, at least in the more anarchic set pieces. The screenplay is credited to Van Robichaux and Evan Susser, with a story credit also going to actor Max Greenfield, and it takes the skeletal premise of a meek English teacher accidentally getting a volatile history teacher sacked on the last day of the school year, then spending the remainder of the day dreading the inevitable consequences. The setting, a high school disintegrating under the chaos of senior pranks, gives the writers room to pile on comic escalation, though how effectively they use that room is very much the question. The film connects in a loose cultural way to the long lineage of workplace comedies built around the fear of physical confrontation, a lineage that runs back through Three O'Clock High (1987) and stretches further still. For a companion piece in a very different register, Friday is worth revisiting: a film that wrings genuine comic tension from similar neighbourhood stakes and does considerably more with the slow burn of a promised confrontation.
The cast assembled here is, on paper at least, a promising mix. Charlie Day, well known from It's Always Sunny, takes the central role of the harassed, increasingly desperate Andy Campbell. Ice Cube, who also served as a producer on the project, plays the terrifyingly implacable history teacher Strickland. Tracy Morgan appears in a supporting role as the school's basketball coach, and Christina Hendricks takes on a memorably unnerving turn as an English teacher with a fondness for a particular concealed weapon. Jillian Bell rounds out the main ensemble as a school counsellor whose conduct is, to put it mildly, professionally questionable. The combination of Day's physical comedy, Ice Cube's particular screen gravity and Bell's flair for the grotesque suggests a film that could have crackled. Whether the material gives them enough to work with is another matter, and one that the review below addresses directly.
Cinematographer Eric Alan Edwards, who has worked previously on films as tonally varied as My Own Private Idaho and the Kids collaboration with Larry Clark, brings a clean, workmanlike look to the school corridors and parking lots. The visual palette is functional rather than stylised: bright, slightly fluorescent institutional lighting that suits the setting without drawing attention to itself. Dominic Lewis provides the score, which sits in the background with the competent, unobtrusive quality of a comedy soundtrack that knows its job is to underline rather than lead. Editor Matthew Freund keeps the ninety-one minute runtime from ever feeling bloated, which is at least something: the film never outstays its welcome in terms of duration, even if it occasionally exhausts its ideas well before the credits roll.
Fist Fight is a one-joke film, and the joke is not strong enough to stretch across ninety minutes.
A mild, put-upon teacher is challenged to an after-school scrap by the most fearsome man on the staff, and the rest is essentially him panicking about it while a chaotic last day of term falls apart around him. It raises the odd laugh, I will give it that, but it is so cartoonishly far-fetched that whatever bite the premise might have had drains straight out of it.
The casting does it no favours at the top. Charlie Day is not much of a lead, and he spends most of the film in a register of frantic, high-pitched flailing that I found more grating than funny. Ice Cube, on the other hand, does exactly what Ice Cube does best, glowering and barking at everyone in sight, and it works perfectly well; you believe him as a man you would go a long way to avoid. Jillian Bell is the other bright spot, landing a few of the biggest laughs as a spectacularly inappropriate guidance counsellor.
The story is dumb, which a comedy this broad could get away with if it were funnier, and it just is not. This is a turn-your-brain-off comedy that forgot to pack quite enough jokes for the job, and it lands a fair way below average as a result. Two stars, and most of them go to Ice Cube for turning up and doing the one thing the film actually needed from him.
Fist Fight lands in a specific and not particularly celebrated corner of the comedy genre: the single-premise farce that generates just enough momentum to justify its runtime but not quite enough invention to transcend it. It is polished but unremarkable, the work of capable hands applying themselves to material that asked for rather more imagination than it received. If the comedy of workplace dread and institutional chaos is something you find yourself drawn to, I also reviewed Mac and Me, another film that carries the weight of a single dubious idea across its full runtime, and the comparison is, in its own way, illuminating. As for Fist Fight itself: it throws a punch, it just does not land it.
Rating: ★★ | Year: 2017 | Watched: 2026-09-10
Trailer
▶ Watch the official trailer for Fist Fight (2017) on YouTube
Where to watch
Watch in the UK
Stream: Netflix · Netflix Standard with Ads
Rent: Apple TV Store · Rakuten TV · Amazon Video · Google Play Movies
Buy: Apple TV Store · Rakuten TV · Amazon Video · Google Play Movies
Physical: Amazon UK · Zavvi
Watch in the US
Stream: fuboTV · Paramount Plus Premium · Paramount Plus Essential · Paramount+ Amazon Channel
Rent: Amazon Video · Apple TV Store · Google Play Movies · YouTube
Buy: Amazon Video · Apple TV Store · Google Play Movies · YouTube
Physical: Amazon US
Affiliate disclosure: Movies With Macca may earn a small commission on purchases or subscriptions started via these links. It costs you nothing extra.
