Captain Marvel (2019)
By the time Marvel Studios released Captain Marvel in March 2019, the Marvel Cinematic Universe was already eleven years and twenty films deep. The studio was weeks away from the release of Avengers: Endgame, and this origin story for Carol Danvers was positioned as something of a bridge: the MCU's first solo female-led film, a deliberate nod to decades of comics history, and a piece of narrative groundwork for what was coming. Set entirely in the 1990s, it plants itself in a period the franchise had never visited before, giving the production designers a nostalgic sandbox to play in (Blockbuster Video, dial-up internet, a very different S.H.I.E.L.D.) while telling the story of an amnesiac Kree warrior who finds herself drawn back to Earth and a past she can't quite remember. The galactic conflict at the film's centre, between the militaristic Kree and the shape-shifting Skrulls, is drawn from a long-running strand of Marvel Comics mythology, though the film takes considerable liberties with the source material in ways that divided readers at the time.
Behind the camera, Marvel took a genuinely unusual choice for a production of this scale. Ryan Fleck and Anna Boden had built their reputations on intimate, character-driven indie work, most notably Half Nelson (2006) and Sugar (2008), films about people in difficult circumstances handled with patience and a light touch. Handing them a blockbuster with a budget in the region of 150 million dollars was a notable gamble, one that generated plenty of pre-release discussion about whether their sensibility would survive contact with the MCU machine. Brie Larson, fresh from her Oscar win for Room (2015), took the lead role of Carol Danvers, bringing with her considerable dramatic credentials and a fair amount of public scrutiny. Samuel L. Jackson returned as a younger Nick Fury, his face digitally de-aged in a process that had become something of a recurring Marvel party trick by this point. If you want a sense of what Jackson can do when the material is actually working for him rather than against him, it is worth checking out Macca's thoughts on Jackie Brown, where he's given real room to breathe. Ben Mendelsohn played the lead Skrull antagonist Talos, doing much of his work under heavy prosthetics, while Jude Law and Annette Bening filled out a supporting cast that, on paper at least, looked polished but unremarkable for a film of this type.
The film arrived to a mixed but broadly positive critical reception and a colossal box office return, comfortably crossing a billion dollars worldwide. For some viewers it was a long-overdue milestone; for others, including quite a few MCU regulars, it felt like competent but oddly flat franchise housekeeping. It is worth noting that Macca has covered another Samuel L. Jackson vehicle from around this era over in his review of Snakes on a Plane, a film that operates in a very different register but similarly tests what star presence alone can and cannot carry.
Being brutally honest, working my way through the billion-dollar box office club on Letterboxd has become an absolute slog. It feels less like a curated cinematic journey and more like I’m trapped in a relentless marathon of the exact same movie, just with different studio logos slapped on the wall.
Whether it’s Aquaman, Black Panther, or Transformers: Dark of the Moon, the formula is exhausting. Ryan Fleck and Anna Boden’s 2019 entry, Captain Marvel, is a prime offender in this tiring assembly line, offering up a cinematic experience that is, quite frankly, more of the same.
The film is undeniably flashy. The CGI is polished to a high sheen, and the cosmic, neon-drenched set pieces are certainly loud and visually busy. But pretty colours can only distract you for so long when the foundation is this wobbly. The script is a complete mess of nonsensical plot twists and clunky exposition, jumping between timelines in a way that feels less like clever, puzzle-box storytelling and more like a desperate attempt to mask a glaring lack of narrative coherence.
Then there is the matter of the performances, which left me entirely cold. Brie Larson does her best to project a stoic, superheroic resolve, but the material she’s handed is so rigid and devoid of genuine human spark that it frequently comes across as remarkably wooden. Even the reliably brilliant Samuel L. Jackson (my most watched actor hilariously), digitally de-aged to within an inch of his life, can’t quite salvage the disjointed, clunky banter he’s forced to deliver. When you have a cast trying to navigate dialogue this poor, the whole enterprise starts to feel like a tedious chore rather than an entertaining blockbuster.
Captain Marvel is a hollow, paint-by-numbers spectacle that perfectly encapsulates my growing fatigue with this tier of modern franchise cinema. It checks all the corporate boxes, delivers the requisite explosions, and rakes in the cash, but it completely fails to offer anything resembling a compelling story or memorable characters. If you’ve seen one of these glossy, soulless blockbusters, you’ve essentially seen them all, and this one certainly doesn't break the mould.
There is something genuinely telling about the fact that a film with this much resource behind it, a strong cast, experienced department heads, and the full weight of the world's most commercially successful franchise, can still leave a thoughtful viewer feeling this flat. The conversation around Captain Marvel has never quite settled, and it probably never will: too many people have too much invested, one way or another, in what it represents. But representation and quality are not the same thing, and conflating them does nobody any favours. If you find yourself sympathising with the kind of franchise fatigue aired above, Macca's review of Jumper covers another high-concept sci-fi property that similarly squandered its premise, and is worth a look for the comparison. Captain Marvel will always have its defenders, and it will always have its detractors. What it may struggle to hold onto, in the long run, is anyone who simply feels much of anything about it at all.
Rating: ★★½ | Year: 2019 | Watched: 2026-07-16
Trailer
▶ Watch the official trailer for Captain Marvel (2019) on YouTube
Where to watch
Watch in the UK
Stream: Disney Plus
Rent: Apple TV Store · Rakuten TV · Amazon Video · Google Play Movies
Buy: Apple TV Store · Rakuten TV · Amazon Video · Google Play Movies
Physical: Amazon UK · Zavvi
Watch in the US
Stream: Disney Plus
Rent: Amazon Video · Apple TV Store · Google Play Movies · YouTube
Buy: Amazon Video · Apple TV Store · Google Play Movies · YouTube
Physical: Amazon US
Affiliate disclosure: Movies With Macca may earn a small commission on purchases or subscriptions started via these links. It costs you nothing extra.
