Old Joy (2006)
★★ — Old Joy (2006)
Kelly Reichardt's Old Joy arrived in 2006 as part of a wave of American independent cinema that prioritised mood and observation over plot. Reichardt, who had made her debut feature River of Grass back in 1994 before a long gap, adapted the film from a short story by Jonathan Raymond, who also co-wrote the screenplay. The two would go on to collaborate repeatedly, and Old Joy is widely regarded as the film that re-established Reichardt as a distinctive voice in low-budget American indie filmmaking. Shot on location in the forests around Portland, Oregon, the film clocks in at a spare 74 minutes and was produced by a small collective of independent production companies, Washington Square Films among them. Its budget was minimal even by indie standards, and the whole project carries the texture of something made with genuine economy, for better and for worse.
The casting is an interesting mix of the familiar and the unexpected. Daniel London, perhaps best known to audiences from his work in Patch Adams, plays Mark, the more settled of the two friends, a man with a baby on the way and a life that has quietly closed around him. Against him, Reichardt cast Will Oldham, the Kentucky-born musician and cult figure (known professionally as Bonnie "Prince" Billy), whose screen presence is deliberately offbeat and difficult to pin down. It is the kind of casting decision that signals exactly what sort of film you are in for: not a polished character study with neat resolutions, but something looser and more interested in texture than arc. The Oregon wilderness does much of the heavy lifting visually, and cinematographer Peter Sillen finds real beauty in the mist and undergrowth. Whether that beauty earns its place in the film is, of course, a fair question. For other films from this same mid-2000s period that took similarly quiet, observational approaches to human experience, it is worth looking at my reviews of Yi Yi and A Bittersweet Life, two films that also sat with their characters for extended stretches, each with rather different results.
The film was well received on the festival circuit and has since accumulated a reputation as a quiet landmark of American slow cinema. Critics who champion it tend to cite its patience and its willingness to leave things unsaid. Those less taken with it point to exactly the same qualities. It is, in other words, a polished but unremarkable piece of work that draws strong reactions in both directions, depending largely on how much weight you are prepared to give its silences. With that in mind, here is what I made of it.
Old Joy (2006) is a minimalist indie drama that follows two old friends reuniting for a weekend camping trip in the forests of Oregon. On paper, it promises introspection, male friendship, and quiet emotional reckoning, but in practice, it delivers little more than meandering small talk and unexamined melancholy. The film leans heavily on atmosphere: misty woods, crackling campfires, and long silences that seem to suggest depth but rarely cohere into meaning. Unfortunately, the dialogue (meant to feel naturalistic) comes across as aimless and underwritten, circling vague anxieties without ever probing them. One friend, Mark (played by Daniel London), is reserved, responsible, and newly expecting a child; the other, Kurt (Will Oldham), is drifting, unkempt, and prone to rambling pseudo-philosophy. While the contrast is clear, Kurt’s behaviour often crosses from “free spirit” into outright childishness, whining about society, making passive-aggressive jabs, and leaning on his friend emotionally without offering anything in return. Rather than evoking empathy, his aimlessness feels self-indulgent, and the film never challenges or examines it critically. At just 76 minutes, Old Joy is mercifully brief, but even that runtime feels padded with empty hikes and half-formed thoughts. There’s no narrative tension, no emotional breakthrough, and ultimately no insight into why this reunion matters. It mistakes stillness for profundity and silence for subtext. Old Joy may appeal to fans of ultra-slow cinema, but for most viewers, it’s a very average film that promises reflection and delivers only drift. Beautiful scenery can’t compensate for thin characters and conversations that go nowhere. Thankfully, it doesn’t overstay its welcome, but it also doesn’t leave much behind.
I find myself coming back to that word "drift", because it really does sum up the experience of watching Old Joy. There is a version of this kind of filmmaking that earns its slowness, where the gaps between words carry genuine feeling and the landscape becomes a kind of emotional shorthand. This, for me, is not quite that film. The Oregon scenery is genuinely lovely, and I can see what Reichardt was reaching for, but reaching is not the same as arriving. If you are curious about drama that uses restraint more productively, my reviews of Mustang and All That's Left of You cover films where the quiet moments actually land. Sometimes less really is more. Sometimes less is just less.
Rating: ★★ | Year: 2006 | Watched: 2026-04-27
Trailer
▶ Watch the official trailer for Old Joy (2006) on YouTube
Where to watch
Watch in the UK
Stream: MUBI · MUBI Amazon Channel
Physical: Amazon UK · Zavvi
Watch in the US
Stream: HBO Max Amazon Channel · Criterion Channel · HBO Max
Physical: Amazon US
Affiliate disclosure: Movies With Macca may earn a small commission on purchases or subscriptions started via these links. It costs you nothing extra.
Related on Movies With Macca
More from the 2000s: Kirikou and the Wild Beasts (2005) · Anchorman: The Legend of Ron Burgundy (2004) · Daredevil (2003) · Apocalypto (2006)
More drama: Viy (1967) · Wonder (2017) · A Better Tomorrow (1986) · Beautiful Boy (2018)
